Best Cities for Homeownership in Indiana

425637_e5ec629bbe_b

by on June 13, 2014

Written by Cherise Fantus

The housing market is booming in Indiana: Sales of existing homes in 2013 were up 17.4% over 2012, and the average home price in that same time increased 4.2% to $122,900, according to the Indiana Business Research Center at Indiana University’s Kelley School of Business.

Much of that growth can be attributed to new jobs. In the past year, Indiana gained 48,000 new jobs, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. As well, Indiana’s personal income increased 2.3% from 2012 to 2013.

NerdWallet crunched the numbers to find the best cities for homeownership in Indiana. Here’s what the best cities had in common:

  • Half of the top 10 cities are near Indianapolis.
  • Home values were less than $200,000 in all but two of the top 20 cities on our list.
  • Seven of the top 10 cities saw their populations grow over 5% from 2010 to 2012.

NerdWallet looked at the 76 communities in Indiana with more than 10,000 residents to determine the best cities for homebuyers. Our analysis answers three main questions:

1. Are homes available? We looked at the area’s homeownership rate to determine the availability of homes. A low homeownership rate is likely a signal of competitive inventory, more options for renters rather than buyers and expensive housing. Areas with a high homeownership rate led to a higher overall score.

2. Can you afford to live there? We looked at median household income, monthly homeowner costs and median home value to assess affordability and determine whether residents could live comfortably in the area. We used monthly homeowner costs to measure cost of living. Areas with high median incomes and low cost of living scored higher. Thinking about buying a home? Learn more about current mortgage rates and mortgage refinancing options in our mortgage guide, as well as whether it’s best to rent or buy.

3. Is the area growing? We measured population growth to ensure that the area is attracting new residents and showing signs of solid growth. This is likely a signal of a robust local economy, which is another attractive characteristic for homebuyers.

For more information on these and other places, check out NerdWallet Cities. For more details on our methodology, see the section at the end of this study. For a full ranking of all 76 cities and to download the raw data, click here.

Top 10 Cities for Homeownership in Indiana

1. Kokomo

Kokomo took the No. 1 spot on our list for its population growth of 18.6% from 2010 to 2012. The city has the lowest monthly homeowner costs at $940 and the lowest median home value of $84,000 of the places on our top 10 list. New homeowners are eligible for the Kokomo Homeowner Investment Program, which assists with exterior improvements. The city is home to several historical sites listed on the National Register of Historic Places, including the Old Silk Stocking Historic District.

2. St. John

St. John residents, who bring in $8,156 a month, earn the highest median monthly household income of any place on our list. The town is located 24 miles southeast of the city of Chicago. On summer Sundays, residents gather at the local farmers market, where dozens of vendors offer fresh fruit and vegetables.

3. Granger

A remarkably high 96.8% of the homes in Granger are owned rather than rented, which is the highest rate on our list. Located northeast of South Bend and its University of Notre Dame, homeowners in Granger pay only 19.6% of their incomes toward homeowner costs — the lowest rate on our list. The area’s major industries are education, health care, social assistance and manufacturing, according to the U.S. Census Bureau.

4. Avon

Avon, located about 15 miles west of Indianapolis, saw an impressive 7.6% population growth from 2010 to 2012. The town school district is one of Avon’s largest employers. For fun, residents take part in annual events like the Avon Community Heritage Festival and the Hendricks County Rib-Fest.

5. Brownsburg

Brownsburg is an affordable place to call home with median monthly homeowner costs of just $1,326. The Lucas Oil Raceway, just on the outskirts of this Indianapolis suburb, provides entertainment for drag racing fans. Brownsburg’s largest employers are the O’Reilly Auto Parts and Home Goods distribution centers.

6. Fishers

This Indianapolis suburb hosts weekly summer farmer’s markets and also has two high schools among the top 10 on the U.S. News Best High Schools in Indiana list. With one of the highest median monthly household incomes on our list at $7,713, homeowners here pay only 21.5% of that income toward monthly mortgage and utility costs.

7. New Haven

The city, just 7 miles east of Fort Wayne, offers one of the most affordable median home values on our list at $93,800. Residents can find jobs at Do It Best Corp., a hardware store chain with its corporate headquarters in nearby Fort Wayne.

8. Noblesville

Noblesville saw its population grow 8.8% from 2010 to 2012. The area is seeing job growth in life sciences and manufacturing, and the largest employers are SMC Corp. of America, which makes pneumatic and automation equipment, and Ambu, a manufacturer of anesthesia and respiratory care products.

9. Dyer

In the town of Dyer, 93.6% of homes are owned rather than rented, which is among the highest rates on our list. Dyer, on the Illinois border, is within commuting distance to jobs in Northwest Illinois and the Chicago area. In the summertime, town residents head to the Dyer Summer Fest for its carnival rides, games and live entertainment.

10. Cedar Lake

Manufacturing, retail trade, health care and social assistance are the top industries in Cedar Lake, according to census data. The town, about 40 miles south of Chicago, has a median home value of $151,400, and median monthly homeowner costs are $1,343, making it an affordable place to live.

 

Rank City Nearest Big City Home Ownership Rate Median Selected Monthly Homeowner Costs Median Monthly Household Income Homeowner Costs as a Percentage of Household Income Median Home Values 2010-2012 Population Growth Overall Score for Home Owners
1 Kokomo Indianapolis 63.5% $940 $3,108 30.2% $84,000 18.6% 76.1
2 St. John Hammond 95.9% $1,771 $8,156 21.7% $254,600 7.4% 68.2
3 Granger South Bend 96.8% $1,491 $7,594 19.6% $192,700 3.3% 67.9
4 Avon Indianapolis 83.4% $1,460 $6,038 24.2% $171,000 7.6% 66.8
5 Brownsburg Indianapolis 81.5% $1,326 $5,435 24.4% $146,000 5.7% 64.6
6 Fishers Indianapolis 83.0% $1,659 $7,713 21.5% $209,500 7.1% 64.2
7 New Haven Fort Wayne 74.2% $1,003 $4,054 24.7% $93,800 5.5% 64.1
8 Noblesville Indianapolis 74.1% $1,423 $5,681 25.1% $168,300 8.8% 63.4
9 Dyer Hammond 93.6% $1,516 $6,573 23.1% $197,500 2.0% 62.5
10 Cedar Lake Hammond 82.1% $1,343 $4,924 27.3% $151,400 3.1% 59.4
11 Crown Point Hammond 78.2% $1,430 $5,406 26.5% $174,900 5.4% 59.4
12 Plainfield Indianapolis 73.5% $1,267 $4,732 26.8% $147,400 4.8% 57.8
13 Jeffersonville Louisville, Ky. 67.0% $1,132 $4,231 26.8% $127,300 6.0% 57.7
14 Decatur Fort Wayne 71.8% $871 $3,512 24.8% $90,300 1.6% 57.3
15 Jasper Evansville 72.0% $1,108 $4,391 25.2% $126,900 2.8% 56.3
16 Greenfield Indianapolis 68.8% $1,135 $4,062 27.9% $121,800 4.1% 55.7
17 Greenwood Indianapolis 62.6% $1,222 $4,633 26.4% $131,700 6.1% 55.4
18 Washington Evansville 66.1% $838 $3,519 23.8% $74,500 1.2% 55.3
19 Franklin Indianapolis 61.4% $1,147 $4,102 28.0% $118,600 6.0% 54.8
20 Munster Hammond 85.2% $1,569 $5,892 26.6% $197,600 0.9% 54.7

For the full ranking of all 76 cities and to download the data, click here.

Methodology

The score for each city was derived from each of these measures:

1. Homeownership rate made up 33.3% of the total score. A higher rate earned a higher score. The rate comes from the U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-year Estimates for all places in the state, Table DP 04.

2. Selected monthly owner costs as a percentage of median household income made up 16.7% of the total score. A lower percentage earned a higher score. Monthly homeowner costs as a percentage of median household income made up one-half of the affordability score. Median household income comes from the U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-year Estimates for all places in the state, Table DP 03. The figure for monthly homeowner costs comes from the U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-year Estimates for all places in the state, Table DP 04.

3. Median home value made up 16.7% of the total score. A lower value earned a higher score. Median home value made up one-half of the affordability score. Median home value comes from the U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-year Estimates for all places in the state, Table DP 04.

4. Population change from 2010 to 2012 made up 33.3% of the total score. A higher percent change earned a higher score. The 2010 population comes from the 2010 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates for all places in the state, Table DP 05. The 2012 population data comes from the 2012 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates for all places in the state, Table DP 05. NerdWallet calculated the percent change.

Only places with 10,000 or more residents were included in this study. Purdue University, a census-designated place, and Westfield were excluded because of a lack of data for all three variables. Zionsville was excluded due to inconsistent population data reporting from 2010 to 2012.

Image: Ben Clark/Flickr: https://flic.kr/p/3bwz

We want to hear from you and encourage a lively discussion among our users. Please help us keep our site clean and safe by following our posting guidelines, and avoid disclosing personal or sensitive information such as bank account or phone numbers. Any comments posted under NerdWallet's official account are not reviewed or endorsed by representatives of financial institutions affiliated with the reviewed products, unless explicitly stated otherwise.
  • Kristin Tortoriello

    So happy to see Dyer, IN on this list, as it is a great place to live! Lots for families to do, great people, and great schools!