Best Places For Renters

renters insurance-resized-600.jpg

by on July 28, 2013

Rental markets can fluctuate wildly by geography. Since 43% of renters are under 30 years old, we wanted to help 20-somethings find the best metropolitans for renters. We looked for metropolitans with affordable rentals and high percentages of renters, which speaks to the size and quality of the rental market.

NerdWallet ranked U.S. cities according to the following questions:

  1. Is there a sizable rental market? We looked at the percentage of total households that are renters to gauge the quality and size of the rental market.
  2. Is renting affordable for the average individual? We looked at the percentage of the monthly median income needed to rent a one-bedroom apartment.

For more information, check out our Cost of Living Calculator and City Life tool.

Best Places for Renters

1. Fargo, ND

Fargo is North Dakota’s largest city, sitting on the western bank of the Red River of the North. A full 46% of households in the area rents, displaying a thriving rental market. Fargo scored well on affordability – the median rent of a one-bedroom apartment is a mere 8% of the monthly median income. The area’s second-largest employer is North Dakota State University, located in Fargo. The Fargo Human Relations Commission launched a Know Your Rights Initiative in 2006 to give the community access and information about their rights and responsibilities as tenants and landlords.

2. Grand Forks, ND

Grand Forks ranks second on our list for its thriving rental market and affordability. It’s North Dakota’s third-largest city and a mere 80 miles away from Fargo. Forty-five percent of the area’s households rent, and the median rent of a one-bedroom apartment is only 9% of the monthly median income. The city is home to Grand Forks Air Base and the University of North Dakota, the oldest and largest university in the state.

3. Ames, IA

Ames is located in Central Iowa, 30 miles north of Des Moines, and is home to the Iowa State University of Science and Technology, the largest employer in the city. There is plenty of affordable rental housing – 45% of the area’s households rent, and the median rent of a one-bedroom apartment is 9% of the median monthly income.

4. Corvallis, OR

Corvallis is situated in Willamette Valley in western Oregon, around 85 miles south of Portland. Oregon State University is just outside downtown Corvallis. The Corvallis area’s rental market is great for OSU students, as rent is very affordable – the median monthly rent for a one-bedroom apartment costs only $578, which is only 8% of the median monthly income.

5. Washington-Arlington-Alexandria, DC/VA

The Washington, D.C. metropolitan area is the largest on our list. A whopping 57% of all households in this region rent. While the median monthly rent of a one-bedroom apartment, at $1,191, is higher than that of all other metropolitan areas on our list, it is only 13% of the median monthly income. Because Washington, D.C. has such a high concentration of renters, the District of Columbia government has an office dedicated specifically to tenant rights and advocacy. Additionally, tenants can find information and educational resources from the D.C. Tenants Advocacy Coalition (TENAC).

6. Lawrence, KS

The Lawrence metropolitan area encompasses all of Douglas County and is centered around the city, which is situated on the banks of Kansas and Wakarusa Rivers. Lawrence is home to the Haskell Indian Nations University and the University of Kansas, Lawrence’s largest employer. Forty-eight percent of Lawrence’s households are renters, and the median monthly rent is only $665 for a one-bedroom apartment, a mere 11% of the median monthly income. The University of Kansas provides information on Consumer and Tenant Affairs to educate and aid student renters on landlord/tenant rights.

7. Blacksburg-Christiansburg-Radford, VA

The Blacksburg-Christiansburg-Radford metropolitan area is located in the New River Valley region of the Appalachian Mountains in western Virginia. The area is home to Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University (Virginia Tech), located in Blacksburg, and Radford University, located in Radford. Virginia Tech’s Office of Student Affairs focuses on protecting students under tenancy laws, providing resources for renters such as information about the Virginia Residential Landlord Tenant Act. The Blacksburg-Christiansburg-Radford area has one of the highest percentages of renters at 45% and a fairly affordable median monthly rent of $645 for a one-bedroom apartment, which is 11% of the median monthly income.

8. Columbia, MO

The fifth-largest city in Missouri, Columbia is the center of the Columbia metropolitan area. The University of Missouri is located in Columbia and is the largest employer. Columbia has some of the most affordable apartments in our list, with the monthly median rent of a one-bedroom apartment of $546. Because 41% of households rent, Columbia’s city government has provided resources for tenants and landlords.

9. Lincoln, NE

Lincoln is the capital and second-largest city in Nebraska. Home to the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, the university is the third-largest employer in the city, after the State of Nebraska and Lincoln Public Schools. Forty-one percent of the households in Lincoln are renters, and one-bedroom apartments cost only 9% of the median monthly income. Nebraska’s RentWise program aims to help tenants learn about tenant rights and responsibilities in Lincoln’s large rental housing market.

10. Bloomington-Normal, IL

The Bloomington-Normal metropolitan area is located in central Illinois, 70 miles northeast of Springfield. 32% of Bloomington-Normal households rent, and rental housing is very affordable. The median monthly rent for a one-bedroom apartment is only $552, which is 7% of the median monthly income. The largest employers are State Farm Insurance, which is headquartered in Bloomington, and Illinois State University, located in Normal. Illinois State University provides legal help for students’ tenant rights and also has an Off-Campus Student Association that provides information and education for student renters.

Rank Metropolitan Percentage of Renter Households Monthly Median Family Income One-Bedroom Average Monthly Rent Overall Score
1 Fargo, ND 46% $6,150 $495 80.3
2 Grand Forks, ND 45% $5,642 $512 76.3
3 Ames, IA 45% $6,242 $578 75.4
4 Corvallis, OR 43% $6,733 $578 75.3
5 Washington-Arlington-Alexandria, D.C./VA 57% $8,942 $1,191 73.4
6 Lawrence, KS 48% $5,900 $664 71.8
7 Blacksburg-Christiansburg-Radford, VA 46% $5,733 $645 69.8
8 Columbia, MO 41% $5,442 $546 69.5
9 Lincoln, NE 38% $5,658 $525 69.2
10 Bloomington-Normal, IL 32% $7,233 $552 69
11 Manhattan, KS 49% $5,092 $631 68.6
12 Lawton, OK 42% $4,567 $489 68.4
13 Greenville, NC 44% $4,800 $545 68.2
14 Lafayette, IN 44% $5,225 $594 68
15 Champaign-Urbana, IL 42% $6,000 $645 67.9
16 Auburn-Opelika, AL 37% $5,250 $490 67.8
17 Bloomington, IN 45% $5,092 $598 67.8
18 Jefferson City, MO 31% $5,675 $440 67.7
19 Lexington-Fayette, KY 39% $5,317 $535 67.6
20 La Crosse, WI 35% $5,767 $520 66.9

Methodology

We scored rental markets with the following metrics:

  1. Is there a sizable rental market? Metropolitans with the highest percentage of households that rent scored higher.
  2. Are rentals affordable? Metropolitans with the lowest percentage of monthly income needed to rent a one-bedroom apartment scored higher.

We included the 567 largest metropolitan areas in the U.S. using data from the Department of Housing and Urban Development and National Low Income Housing Coalition.

We want to hear from you and encourage a lively discussion among our users. Please help us keep our site clean and safe by following our posting guidelines, and avoid disclosing personal or sensitive information such as bank account or phone numbers. Any comments posted under NerdWallet's official account are not reviewed or endorsed by representatives of financial institutions affiliated with the reviewed products, unless explicitly stated otherwise.
  • Guest

    This may be one of the stupidest things I’ve ever seen, at least as regards DC. Do you honestly think that most people who make 8 or 9 grand a month are renting a $1200/month apartment? I don’t suppose it has occurred to you to actually learn how medians work. Here’s a tip: calculate the median income of this group of three people: one earns 25k per year, one earns 50k per year, and one earns $4 million per year. Then calculate how happy the first two of those people are going to be to be unable to find any damn thing to rent in the DC area that’s less than $1100 per month.

    • jaanku

      hear hear! All of these articles about DC always seem to misrepresent the real situation for people renting in the district. Why so many renters? Because it’s too expensive to buy. And it’s ludicrous to lump DC/Arlington/Alexandria into the same bucket. Furthermore, anything east of the Anacostia brings the median prices too low. Adjust your numbers for anything in the DC mainland and you’ll get a very different picture.

  • Erin

    Are we mixing up mean and median here? The 50th percentile in household income in the D.C. area is 100,000? I don’t think so. The average probably is, but as the other commenter suggested, that doesn’t matter much to most people. Also household v. individual income isn’t specified. Are you sure you’re nerds?

    • NWDivya

      Thanks for your feedback. The data listed is the median family income for the DC metro area according to the Department of Housing and Urban Development and the U.S. Census.