Most Expensive Cities for Car Insurance

shutterstock_135440300

Drivers in some U.S. cities will face higher car insurance premiums in 2014. Car insurance rates vary significantly across the country, and some citizens will pay significantly more depending on where they live.

NerdWallet found the most expensive car insurance premiums in the country because high car insurance premiums can have a large financial and political impact on people’s lives. Drivers, for the most part, cannot control the major factors causing high car insurance premiums. Bad weather, traffic conditions, high crime rates, local laws and congestion all contribute to high car insurance costs.  Even so, they can lower their rates by comparing insurance carriers and searching for discounts. We have found that on average drivers overpay $368 for car insurance every year.

Methodology:

To find the average car insurance rates of the 125 largest cities in the United States, we used the profile of a 26-year-old male without any history of accidents, insuring a 2012 Toyota Camry with extended coverage (100/300/50 with a 500 deductible). In calculating averages for each city, we only used zip codes within city limits and not in the city’s metro area.

Key Findings:

  • Detroit’s average car insurance rates are more than ten times that of the Winston-Salem, North Carolina, the city with the lowest average
  • State laws play a key role in a city’s car insurance rates
  • Car insurance rates vary greatly from zip code to zip code

Detroit has the most expensive average car insurance premiums in the country. At $10,723.22, Detroit’s average rates are more than twice as the second most expensive city, New Orleans. The city’s rates are so high that Mike Duggan, Detroit’s newly elected mayor, made lowering car insurance premiums a major part of his campaign platform.

Politics and law play a major role in a city’s car insurance rates. All of the most expensive cities for car insurance were in states with no-fault car insurance laws. Large cities such as New York and Los Angeles have cheaper average premiums than small cities such as Grand Rapids and Baton Rouge, which are in no-fault states. 

Here are the most expensive cities for car insurance in the U.S:

(Interested in your area’s car insurance costs? Check out NerdWallet’s car insurance tool here.)

Cities with the Most Expensive Car Insurance

1. Detroit, Michigan

Average annual premium: $10,723.22

The Motor City is known for its cars, but its car insurance premiums are the highest in the nation. In Detroit, drivers face high rates because of the city’s high crime rate and Michigan’s no-fault insurance system. Under state law, insurance companies must pay medical expenses, lost wages and property damage regardless of who caused an accident. The system is intended to reduce litigation costs and ensure prompt claim repayment, but many complain that costs have ballooned because lawmakers have not set a cap on claim awards.

Detroit’s annual insurance premiums are not uniformly high. We found that even within neighborhoods, Detroit’s annual insurance premiums varied greatly. In the Rosedale Park neighborhood, State Farm offers a policy for $25,300 a year, while Hanover offers insurance for a fraction of the price at $4,854.

2. New Orleans, Louisiana

Average annual premium: $4,309.61

Annual premiums in New Orleans might look cheap compared to Detroit, but the average annual cost still equals about 12 percent of the city’s median household income, according to census figures. Residents commute 22.8 minutes to work on average, and New Orleans has some of the worst maintained roads in the country. Also contributing to high rates is a state law that also allows drivers to directly sue insurance companies after an accident. In Louisiana, juries only decide claims exceeding $50,000. The rest go before a judge or are settled.

3. Grand Rapids, Michigan

Average annual premium: $4,042.42

With 189,813 residents, Grand Rapids is much smaller than Detroit. However, Grand Rapids drivers still suffer from Michigan’s no-fault insurance laws and bad weather. Bad weather often exacerbates road deterioration. TRIP, a non-profit, estimates Grand Rapids’ potholes cost motorists $1,027 a year.

4. Newark, New Jersey

Average annual premium: $3,525.43

Like Michigan, New Jersey also has a no-fault insurance.  In addition to state law, Newark’s high insurance rates may result from its close proximity to New York and New Jersey’s snowy winters. Newark drivers have an average commute of 31.3 minutes to work, which is a bit higher than the national average, 25.4 minutes.

New Jersey residents enrolled in Medicaid can save money under the state’s special Automobile Insurance Policy (SAIP). SAIP provides low-cost car insurance to those who might not be able to afford it, though it only covers post-accident medical costs.

5. Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Average annual premium: $3,363.73

Louisiana’s capital is smaller than New Orleans by 130,000 residents, and drivers save nearly $1,000 yearly on their average premium. But locals endure traffic congestion and roads in disrepair, and the average cost still accounts for about 8.6 percent of the city’s median household income, according to the U.S. Census.

6. Hialeah, Florida

Average annual premium: $3,271.86

Hialeah is a major commercial center in Miami-Dade County and its drivers pay the highest premiums in Florida. One reason for Hialeah’s high premiums is that Florida has no-fault insurance laws and frequent hurricanes.  Since Hurricane Andrew in 1992, Florida has been hit by seven major hurricanes.

7. Jersey City, New Jersey

Average annual premium: $3,266.63

Nestled between Newark and New York City is Jersey City. Drivers must deal with many of the same traffic issues – notably high congestion — and often face icy winters. The city, however, is much wealthier than Newark, and the average premium accounts for only 5.6 percent of the median household income in Jersey City. On average, residents travel 35 minutes to work.

8. Louisville, Kentucky

Average annual premium: $3,255.99

Although Louisville has mild winters compared to Detroit and Newark, Louisville, like all of the other cities on this list, resides in a state with no-fault car insurance laws. Louisville, according to Neighborhoodscout.com, is more dangerous than 83 percent of U.S. cities, and has an especially high number of auto thefts.

9. Miami, Florida

Average annual premium: $3,168.75

Miami is in a state with no-fault insurance and it is also victim to hurricanes, but according to a few studies, Miami also seems to have bad drivers. Miami suffers from extreme congestion and was ranked as the city with the rudest drivers in the U.S. According to an Allstate study Miami has the ninth worst drivers in the U.S., meaning that they have a 58.4 percent greater-than-average accident frequency.

10. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Average annual premium: $2,930.53

Philadelphia drivers deal with many factors contributing to high car insurance costs. They face unfavorable car insurance laws because Pennsylvania is a no-fault state. Philadelphia also faces cold winters and year-round congestion. Drivers who have trouble finding affordable car insurance can apply to the Pennsylvania Assigned Risk Plan.

Rank City State Population Average Car Insurance Price
1 Detroit city MI 706,640 $10,723.22
2 New Orleans LA 360,740 $4,309.61
3 Grand Rapids MI 189,813 $4,042.42
4 Newark NJ 277,545 $3,525.43
5 Baton Rouge LA 230,148 $3,363.73
6 Hialeah FL 229,967 $3,271.86
7 Jersey City NJ 250,317 $3,266.63
8 Louisville KY 602,037 $3,255.99
9 Miami FL 408,760 $3,168.75
10 Philadelphia PA 1,536,471 $2,930.53
11 Shreveport city LA 201,871 $2,901.23
12 Chicago IL 2,707,123 $2,859.36
13 New York City NY 8,244,910 $2,712.43
14 Boston MA 624,969 $2,681.00
15 Tampa FL 346,064 $2,663.43
16 Lexington KY 301,569 $2,652.11
17 Las Vegas NV 589,340 $2,618.59
18 Minneapolis MN 387,736 $2,602.06
19 St. Paul MN 288,437 $2,554.29
20 Honolulu HI 340,931 $2,515.38
21 North Las Vegas NV 219,017 $2,504.10
22 Los Angeles CA 3,819,708 $2,307.57
23 Henderson NE 260,072 $2,301.29
24 Glendale CA 193,113 $2,276.11
25 St. Louis MO 318,069 $2,271.58
26 Atlanta GA 432,425 $2,224.76
27 St. Petersburg FL 244,995 $2,218.35
28 Houston TX 2,145,933 $2,211.62
29 Yonkers NY 197,397 $2,194.56
30 Baltimore MD 619,493 $2,172.23

NerdWallet also found the cities with the cheapest average car insurance.

Detroit via Shutterstock

We want to hear from you and encourage a lively discussion among our users. Please help us keep our site clean and safe by following our posting guidelines, and avoid disclosing personal or sensitive information such as bank account or phone numbers. Any comments posted under NerdWallet's official account are not reviewed or endorsed by representatives of financial institutions affiliated with the reviewed products, unless explicitly stated otherwise.