The Best Cities in Idaho for Young Families

Idaho state

by on September 21, 2013

Families may visit Idaho for its natural spaces, but they settle down for more, including educational opportunities for their kids.

With that in mind, we asked the following questions as we analyzed cities and places across the state:

  1. Does the city have good public schools? We measured schools’ academic performance with ratings from GreatSchools. This non-profit compares a given school’s standardized test scores to the state average to obtain a rating on a 1 to 10 scale (10 representing the highest score). Higher ratings led to a higher overall score.
  2. Can you afford to live there? We looked at both median home values in each city and ongoing monthly home costs, including mortgage payments, real estate taxes, insurance costs, utilities, fuel and other bills. Lower costs led to a higher overall score.
  3. Is the city growing and prospering? We assessed a city’s economy by looking at median household income and income growth over the last decade. Higher income and greater growth led to a higher overall score.

Check out our cost of living calculator here as well as our mortgage rates calculator for more information.

The Best Cities for Young Families

1. McCall

McCall sits on the southern edge of Payette Lake, which is known for its boating and beaches. A local high school, McCall-Donnelly, boasts a 99% graduation rate. MDHS is also an Idaho Department of Education 5-star school, a designation given to schools for student growth, proficiency and participation on standardized tests.

2. Rigby

Rigby is the seat of Jefferson County, in the central-eastern region of the state. In the last decade, the county saw significant growth, with civilian employment increasing by 10.8% from 1996 to 2006. The government and the trade sector are the biggest employers in the area.

3. Kimberly

Kimberly is in the northwest region of Twin Falls County, located along the south-central border of Idaho. Kimberly High School was awarded a “Go On” grant, which offers $10,000 to $40,000 in funding to support students’ pursuits after high school.

4. Ammon

Ammon is located in the Upper Snake River Valley, to the east of Idaho Falls. Between 2000 and 2010, Ammon saw its population double; it grew by 123.3%. The city has grown so quickly because of its relatively low housing prices and proximity to Idaho Falls, the state’s largest city outside the Boise metro area.

5. Rathdrum

Located along Idaho’s western panhandle, Rathdrum is just a few miles from Coeur d’Alene, one of the state’s largest metropolitan areas. The larger county boasts 245,000 acres of national forest area. Rathdrum in particular is surrounded by mountains and is in close proximity to thirteen lakes, making it a popular location for families who love the outdoors.

6. Malad City

Malad City is the only incorporated city in Oneida County, which rests along the southeastern edge of Idaho. The city is located close to more than half a dozen universities and technical colleges and a larger metro area, Salt Lake City, 100 miles south.

7. Sandpoint

Sandpoint lies in the northern tip of Idaho and on the shores of Lake Pend Oreille, the state’s largest lake. In the last several years, the city has grown significantly, particularly in the retail and manufacturing sectors. The job market for the latter nearly doubled between 1996 and 2006.

8. Dalton Gardens 

Dalton Gardens is on the northern border of Coeur d’Alene, the fourth-fastest growing housing market in the nation. Top employers in Dalton Gardens include service, retail and government.

9. Eagle

Eagle is a suburb of the state capital, Boise. Running through the city is the Boise River, and just a couple miles away is one of the area’s most popular recreational spaces, the Greenbelt, a 25-mile green pathway that runs along the water’s edge.

10. Orofino

Orofino is the seat of Clearwater County, and it is known for its fresh air and beautiful scenery. Clearwater River runs through the city, and the surrounding landscape gives residents an opportunity to hike, ski, hunt, golf and fish.

Rank City Nearest big city GreatSchools rating Median home value Monthly owner costs Median household income Growth,’99-’11 Overall score for young families
1 McCall 8 $237,000 $1,409 $54,545 50.5% 77.1
2 Rigby Idaho Falls 7 $132,200 $1,024 $45,089 49.3% 74.1
3 Kimberly Twin Falls 8 $119,100 $1,012 $39,450 16.4% 71.4
4 Ammon Idaho Falls 8 $173,900 $1,305 $55,617 16.3% 71.2
5 Rathdrum Coeur d’Alene 8 $167,200 $1,265 $47,285 14.9% 69.9
6 Malad City 7 $113,800 $1,033 $38,750 20.2% 66.7
7 Sandpoint 7 $217,800 $1,282 $41,851 28.9% 65.7
8 Dalton Gardens Coeur d’Alene 7 $338,000 $1,612 $58,269 30.8% 64.5
9 Eagle Boise 7 $332,100 $1,970 $80,724 23.6% 64.4
10 Orofino 5 $113,300 $911 $45,536 48.9% 64.1

Methodology

The overall score for each city was derived from the following measures:

  1. GreatSchools city rating. GreatSchools city ratings are calculated by averaging the weighted overall rating for each school in the city (weighted by the number of students enrolled at the school)
  2. Median home value from the U.S. Census (2011 ACS, data set DP04, half-weighted)
  3. Monthly homeowner costs from the U.S. Census (2011 ACS, data set DP04, half-weighted)
  4. Median household income from the U.S. Census (2011 ACS, data set DP03, half-weighted)
  5. Income change between 1999 and 2011 from the U.S. Census (data sets P053 and DP03, half-weighted)

63 Idaho cities and areas designated as places by the U.S. Census were included in this analysis. Only places with a population greater than 2,000 were considered.

More from NerdWallet

We want to hear from you and encourage a lively discussion among our users. Please help us keep our site clean and safe by following our posting guidelines, and avoid disclosing personal or sensitive information such as bank account or phone numbers. Any comments posted under NerdWallet's official account are not reviewed or endorsed by representatives of financial institutions affiliated with the reviewed products, unless explicitly stated otherwise.
  • kadesmith

    I’m surprised Rexburg, “America’s Family Community” did not make this list.

    • http://www.nerdwallet.com/ NerdWallet

      Hi kadesmith,

      Rexburg was close! It ranked number 15 on our list. The cost of homeownership is reasonable, and schools in Rexburg are excellent. The only thing keeping it from ranking higher was income; median household income was lower, at $26k, whereas most Idaho towns hover around $40k.

      • kadesmith

        It’s all the students who are not working. They skew the data every time one of these studies are done. Move the university to Rigby, and the data would flip.