ADVERTISER DISCLOSURE

The Best Towns in Montana for Young Families

montana

by on December 2, 2013

When young families settle down, they look for more than a plot and four walls. They invest in the community and all it offers, from the local schools to the local economy. We wanted to identify the communities with the best of the best in those categories, so we asked the following questions as we analyzed cities and towns across the state:

  1. Does the town have good public schools? We measured schools’ academic performance with ratings from GreatSchools. This non-profit compares a given school’s standardized test scores to the state average to obtain a rating on a 1 to 10 scale (10 representing the highest score). Higher ratings led to a higher overall score.
  2. Can you afford to live there? We looked at both median home values in each town and ongoing monthly home costs, including mortgage payments, real estate taxes, insurance costs, utilities, fuel and other bills. Lower costs led to a higher overall score.
  3. Is the town growing and prospering? We assessed a town’s economy by looking at median household income and income growth over the last decade. Higher income and greater growth led to a higher overall score.

Check out our cost of living calculator here as well as our mortgage rates calculator for more information.

What makes these towns great? Let us know in the comments below.

The Best Towns for Young Families

1. Columbus

Columbus lies on the northern bank of the Yellowstone River, about 40 miles west of Billings. The town also serves as the gateway to the Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness and Yellowstone National Park. Columbus High School is one of the best in the state – it was one of just three Montana schools to receive a National Blue Ribbon in 2012.

2. Sidney         

Sidney is the seat of Richland County, near the state’s eastern border. The city is a major retail center in the region, drawing people from eastern Montana and western North Dakota. Recreational opportunities are great here, too, with an 18-hole golf course, an Olympic-size swimming pool and the only indoor hockey arena in the eastern half of the state.

3. Bozeman

Bozeman is the seat of Gallatin County, which has seen tremendous growth in the last several years. One in every 10 new businesses in the state started up in the county. The population of Bozeman, too, grew by 35 percent over the last decade. Montana State University is also in town, and it offers baccalaureate degrees in 60 different fields, master’s in 45 and doctoral in 20.

4. Dillon 

Dillon is the seat of Beaverhead County and home to the University of Montana Western, which serves residents of all ages in its academic, community-service and lifelong-learning programs. In 2009, one of the college’s professors, Dr. Robert C. Thomas, was recognized as one of the Professors of the Year by the Chronicle of Higher Education. Outside of higher education, Dillon has made a name for itself, too. As the center of Montana’s largest cattle and hay-producing area, it is one of the state’s agricultural hubs.

5. Bigfork

Bigfork is in northwestern Montana, in Flathead County. The community hugs Flathead Lake, the largest natural freshwater lake west of the Mississippi with its 180 miles of shoreline. The lake gives residents a place to boat, fish and more. The town also prides itself on its support of the arts, with its galleries and theatre making it “One of the 100 Best Small Arts Towns in the West”, according to the area chamber of commerce.

6. Lockwood 

Lockwood is the second-largest community in the Billings metro area. It grew quite a bit last decade, too, by 57.8 percent. With its transition from rural community to booming city, Lockwood has planned to expand infrastructure to continue to serve its residents at full capacity.

7. Shelby

Shelby is the seat of Toole County, near the northern border of Montana. The larger area is big in agriculture. Shelby is near the center of the Golden Triangle, which produces 70 percent of the barley and 60 percent of the wheat in Montana. The community has seen growth in the energy sector as well, and the local government expects the industry to continue to expand.

8. Lolo 

Lolo is in the Missoula metro area, which topped National Geographic’s list of “Next Great Adventure Towns: Rockies” in 2008 because of the surrounding mountains and trails. One mile south of Lolo is Traveler’s Rest State Park, the only campsite on the Lewis and Clark Trail with physical evidence of the explorers’ expedition.

9. Livingston

Livingston is on the banks of the Yellowstone River. The 7,000-person community was the original gateway to Yellowstone National Park, too, which is now just 50 miles away. The city itself includes four districts recognized by the National Register of Historic Places, including residential parts of town and the city’s downtown area.

10. Kalispell

Kalispell is the seat of Flathead County, and it is just 45 minutes from the 1 million-acre Glacier National Park. Visitors can go to the park to boat in the summer and cross-country ski in the winter. Kalispell’s grown tremendously in the last several years, with 40.1 percent population growth between 2000 and 2010.

Rank City Nearest big city GreatSchools rating Median home value Monthly owner costs Median household income Growth,’99-’11 Overall score for young families
1 Columbus Billings 8 $148,100 $1,153 $52,443 55.4% 67.7
2 Sidney 7 $106,600 $965 $55,202 71.9% 66.9
3 Bozeman 9 $269,000 $1,564 $44,412 38.1% 65.5
4 Dillon Butte 8 $132,100 $1,093 $35,917 36.1% 64.7
5 Bigfork Kalispell 8 $334,600 $1,613 $51,250 41.9% 61.1
6 Lockwood Billings 7 $142,600 $1,047 $44,909 29.2% 60.9
7 Shelby 6 $104,700 $934 $44,086 50.9% 59.9
8 Lolo Missoula 7 $217,600 $1,516 $60,112 37.1% 59.8
9 Livingston Bozeman 7 $164,600 $1,154 $36,797 27.0% 59.0
10 Kalispell 7 $197,000 $1,312 $39,205 37.2% 59.0
11 Glasgow 6 $88,100 $904 $41,220 35.2% 58.5
12 Miles City 6 $88,500 $881 $39,787 33.3% 58.3
13 Colstrip 5 $115,600 $1,021 $77,337 39.0% 57.3
14 Butte 6 $122,200 $971 $40,485 32.7% 57.3
15 Hamilton Missoula 7 $154,800 $996 $24,278 10.3% 57.1
16 Townsend Helena 6 $131,600 $1,053 $36,580 36.4% 56.8
17 Red Lodge Billings 8 $202,600 $1,099 $46,354 46.0% 56.5
18 Billings 6 $172,900 $1,272 $47,869 36.2% 56.2
19 Whitefish Kalispell 7 $310,200 $1,416 $41,940 26.9% 55.9
20 Missoula 7 $238,100 $1,502 $37,316 22.9% 55.9
21 Glendive 5 $112,300 $1,019 $47,292 52.8% 55.7
22 Deer Lodge Butte 5 $89,000 $859 $41,351 38.5% 54.9
23 Conrad Great Falls 5 $79,500 $888 $39,167 33.1% 54.2
24 Laurel Billings 5 $150,000 $1,077 $46,530 42.4% 53.8
25 Polson Kalispell 5 $177,600 $1,113 $33,800 54.5% 53.0
26 Belgrade Bozeman 6 $192,700 $1,268 $41,806 11.8% 53.0
27 Great Falls 5 $149,900 $1,125 $42,540 31.2% 52.1
28 Lewistown 5 $99,100 $911 $34,089 17.8% 51.8
29 Stevensville Missoula 5 $168,600 $1,190 $33,527 19.9% 49.6
30 Anaconda Butte 4 $105,700 $925 $34,095 29.6% 48.6
31 Helena 4 $192,500 $1,316 $47,749 38.7% 47.7
32 Havre 3 $116,400 $1,072 $46,132 54.1% 47.2
33 Libby 4 $108,400 $780 $27,396 12.9% 47.0
34 Malta 4 $80,300 $804 $30,863 -1.1% 46.4
35 Columbia Falls Kalispell 4 $182,200 $1,143 $37,196 19.5% 45.7
36 West Glendive $120,600 $945 $63,750 90.4% 44.6
37 Lame Deer 1 $51,300 $422 $35,089 77.0% 44.0
38 Wolf Point 2 $62,200 $906 $35,929 28.5% 41.3
39 Ronan Missoula, Kalispell 2 $117,200 $927 $31,708 41.4% 41.1
40 East Missoula Missoula $189,900 $1,358 $51,364 89.6% 40.3
41 Pablo Missoula, Kalispell 3 $64,300 $944 $20,807 -22.3% 38.9
42 North Browning $70,000 $544 $32,262 32.2% 38.6
43 Cut Bank $73,700 $766 $43,125 27.3% 38.2
44 Helena Valley Southeast Helena $162,000 $1,303 $56,703 48.6% 37.7
45 Four Corners Bozeman $317,000 $1,748 $67,802 83.4% 37.5
46 Montana City Helena $301,300 $1,654 $90,603 37.2% 36.1
47 Helena Valley Northwest Helena $198,200 $1,368 $61,607 35.7% 36.0
48 Helena Valley Northeast Helena $307,600 $1,650 $76,364 50.3% 35.8
49 Hardin Billings 1 $90,200 $783 $31,193 11.3% 35.1
50 South Browning $50,400 - $30,648 152.7% 34.7
51 Helena Valley West Central Helena $210,800 $1,525 $58,082 32.4% 34.5
52 Orchard Homes Missoula $265,700 $1,414 $53,185 32.2% 33.5
53 Evergreen Kalispell $159,300 $1,209 $31,696 7.6% 31.8
54 Big Sky Bozeman $537,500 $2,013 $57,179 44.1% 27.8
55 Malmstrom AFB Great Falls - - $38,721 21.9% 7.3

Methodology

The overall score for each city was derived from the following measures:

  1. GreatSchools city rating. GreatSchools city ratings are calculated by averaging the weighted overall rating for each school in the city (weighted by the number of students enrolled at the school)
  2. Median home value from the U.S. Census (2011 ACS, data set DP04, half-weighted)
  3. Monthly homeowner costs from the U.S. Census (2011 ACS, data set DP04, half-weighted)
  4. Median household income from the U.S. Census (2011 ACS, data set DP03, half-weighted)
  5. Income change between 1999 and 2011 from the U.S. Census (data sets P053 and DP03, half-weighted)

55 Montana cities and areas designated as places by the U.S. Census were included in this analysis. Only places with a population greater than 2,000 were considered.

More from NerdWallet

We want to hear from you and encourage a lively discussion among our users. Please help us keep our site clean and safe by following our posting guidelines, and avoid disclosing personal or sensitive information such as bank account or phone numbers. Any comments posted under NerdWallet's official account are not reviewed or endorsed by representatives of financial institutions affiliated with the reviewed products, unless explicitly stated otherwise.
  • Seth Ward

    Some very odd choices here. Sidney #2, Colstrip in the top 1000? Moral: never move anywhere based on statistics.

  • Mitch Staley

    As a 24-year-old, third-generation Dillonite, I’m happy to see Dillon get recognized on this list. We have great schools, a University and a new hospital that has been ranked in the top 100 list of Critical Access Hospitals in the nation for the last two-years. On top of that, we have two exits on I-15 N/S and access to an abundance of multiple use public lands. Great hunting, fishing and outdoors activity. We’re also proud of the work we do downtown and in the field. Dillon is renovating it’s downtown area (privately done by individual businesses and property owners), which is making Dillon an attractive retail destination. We are home to Great Harvest Franchise offices, a Patagonia Outlet, Frecker’s Saddlery, The Bookstore, Diamond K Trading, The Daily Yarn, The Dilmart, Schwartz Custom Boots, Bitteroot Trading Post, Barretts Minerals and many great shops and restaurants. We’re also in the heart of rich western/pioneer history. Again, glad to see we made the list!

  • Watchingtheweasels

    I too agree that this is a strange list. Helena, Dillion, Shelby, Kalispell, Whitefish are all wonderful places. But Havre? The place is a dumpy, run down town sandwiched between two reservations.

  • Vruko .

    I am looking to move my family too Montana. We are interested in at least a house and 10 acres of land. But close enough to people so our 7 year old son can be near friends, school, etc. Where do you suggest?