Expert FAQ: How Can States Encourage Drivers to Buy Car Insurance?

Auto Insurance, Insurance
car insurance states

Getting in a car accident is never any fun, but at least insurance will cover your repairs – that is, if both drivers are insured. Unfortunately, for many in the U.S., that’s not a safe assumption, despite state minimum car insurance requirements. 

Earlier this month, the Insurance Research Council estimated that 12.6% of drivers on American roads were uninsured, and in some states, it’s closer to 25% – or more.

“My guess is whatever numbers you find about uninsured motorists are low compared to what they really are,” says Dr. Jack Taylor, Joseph S. Bruno professor of retailing at Birmingham-Southern College.

Uninsured driving is a safety issue, and most states have taken aggressive measures to limit the number of drivers without coverage on their roads. But there are no quick fixes, and as Robert Hood, community prosecution director for the Association of Prosecuting Attorneys points out, “States are all over the map in what they try to do to solve the problem.”

Why don’t some drivers buy auto insurance? 

Experts agree that economics is a major cause of uninsured driving.

“The unemployment rate and the number of uninsured drivers are pretty closely correlated. When people lose their jobs, auto insurance is often one of the first things they consider dropping,” explains Dr. Tim Query, associate professor of finance at New Mexico State University.

Not only can low-income drivers have a hard time paying premiums, but they also may not see the point of coverage. “Low-income people may not need to protect their assets,” says Linda Sherry, director of national priorities at Consumer Action. “They may not understand that insurance protects your property, as well as you if you make a mistake.”

Some drivers in uncertain legal situations may also go uninsured. Because many carriers require a driver’s license number to sign up for coverage, undocumented immigrants may drive without insurance.

Culture can also play a part, Query says: “In New Mexico, we have a lot of Mexican immigrants, and auto insurance isn’t so important there. If drivers are in an accident, they might just settle up with cash on the spot.”

Hood sees similar issues with those who drive on suspended licenses.“It’s not unusual that they also get cited for failing to maintain insurance,” he says. 

How can states encourage drivers to buy car insurance? 

Different states have tried to address every angle of the uninsured driver problem. However, each has a unique cultural and legal landscape, making comparison difficult.

Some states have responded by beefing up fees and other penalties. Hood has seen many states and cities impound uninsured vehicles. California and the city of Dallas both allow the towing of first-time offenders. Some – including New York and Ohio – reserve the right to suspend uninsured drivers’ licenses and make them pay the reinstatement costs.

Others rely on technology to identify uninsured drivers. “Some states have created the computer capacity to confirm that you’re insured at the time you get a plate,” Hood adds.

Getting insurance isn’t enough – drivers must maintain it.

“In Alabama, they’ll actually take your tag away if you’re driving without insurance,” Taylor says. “Some places also have laws where if you terminate your policy, or it lapses, or is canceled, your insurer notifies the state. Or if a police officer stops you, they can check instantly whether your insurance is valid.”

Others aren’t convinced stricter penalties are the way to go. “I’m not so sure legal penalties are the issue,” Sherry suggests. “Do people understand that they can get lower-cost insurance? Do they understand the importance of being insured?”

To this end, California has created a low-cost auto insurance program, targeting low-income and minority consumers. Eligible driversmust meet income guidelines and maintain a generally clean driving record. If they do, they can purchase coverage for a maximum of $338 per year, depending on their county.  Most states also have assigned risk pools that can help drivers with blemished records access insurance.

A handful of states have legalized driver’s licenses – or privilege cards – for undocumented immigrants. Proponents of these laws often argue that by enabling all drivers to pass the same tests, they make roads safer. The laws can also enable access to insurance.

But simply having these programs isn’t enough. Sherry emphasizes the role of education – in program publicity and insurance in general: “There’s a lot states can do. They can work with community groups, communities of color and limited English speakers to get the word out that it’s vital to have car insurance, and to let consumers know that these programs exist. California works with us to disseminate the brochure about their low-cost insurance program. Using all the available avenues to get the word out once you have a good solution is very important.” 

What works? 

The jury is still out on most of these enforcement methods. Many areas lack research, and what research exists is often mixed. In addition, what works for one community may not work for another.

Take undocumented immigrant licensing, for example. Query’s research has found that states that allow undocumented immigrants driving privileges see varying rates of uninsured drivers: “New Mexico is still one of the highest, and Utah is still one of the lowest.” Though both states’ rates of uninsured drivers have trended downward in recent years, they’ve only moved a few places in overall rankings – and New Mexico’s estimated rate still tops 20%.

As for stricter penalties, Query believes they’re “somewhat helpful,” especially when combined with automatic verification programs, which alert states if drivers drop insurance. This detects drivers who may buy, then immediately drop insurance. It also means troopers in these states need not always stop  drivers to find out whether they’re uninsured.

“I don’t know if anybody’s researched the low-cost insurance rates yet,” Query adds. “That’s definitely something to look at.”

“It’s a growing trend for states to impound uninsured vehicles, but there’s not been a formal evaluation” of its effectiveness, Hood notes.

Drivers have a much easier choice than states when it comes to protection from uninsured drivers.

“Uninsured motorists coverage is the best way to protect yourself from uninsured drivers,” Taylor recommends. “In some states, you can go without it, but nobody should ever, ever do that.”


Car insurance illustration via Shutterstock