Paycor Review 2021: Features, Pricing, User Reviews

Learn about Paycor's features, pricing, reviews and top competitors to decide if it's right for your business.
Brian O'ConnorOct 28, 2020

Many or all of the products featured here are from our partners who compensate us. This may influence which products we write about and where and how the product appears on a page. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own. Here is a list of our partners and here's how we make money.

There are tons of options within the payroll software space and each comes with its own advantages and disadvantages. Our Paycor review will outline the pros and cons, features, pricing and customer reviews of this software provider — and explore some of its competitors as well.

What is Paycor?

Not every small business can afford to hire and employ a full-time HR staff, and in some cases, hiring a team of professionals is more than what’s needed — particularly for small businesses. In most scenarios, however, HR and payroll tasks end up falling on the shoulders of other employees as a second responsibility. That can lead to oversized workloads, confusion about responsibilities and mistakes made by untrained professionals. But, for many years, the only other recourse would be to hire a part-time staffer or team to aid with this work, which was a costly proposition for many small businesses.

Paycor offers a suite of tools that help business owners manage all aspects of their HR and payroll administration. Instead of hiring a team dedicated to things like recruiting, onboarding, employee management, benefits administration and payroll, Paycor can handle the bulk of the work through its software suite.

How Paycor works

Paycor works by essentially creating a cloud-based HR system that can, for most tasks, replace a dedicated on-site HR and payroll staff. Because most tasks are automated, Paycor and its competitors can offer these tools as a less expensive alternative to live, outsourced support.

Paycor provides a suite of tools that empower small-business owners to manage their HR and payroll tasks with confidence. The platform makes it easy to customize by parceling out many common tasks into individual parts of a larger software offering. This way, business owners can purchase what they need without paying for tools they don’t use (or can manage on their own).

Who is Paycor for?

Paycor is a great option for small- and medium-sized business owners who may have companies that are large enough to have a need for professional HR services, but that may not be at a point in which hiring a full-time HR professional is justifiable. These tools can help bridge the divide between managing all of your company’s people and payroll tasks and hiring an expert. This frees up budget and headcount for other areas of your operation, which can be particularly helpful if you’re filling roles strategically to keep business booming.

Even if the above doesn’t quite fit the description of your business or needs, there are likely other reasons why Paycor might be for you. The software Paycor offers can be bundled together, but it doesn’t necessarily have to be. If you only need help with something like benefits administration, for example, you can sign up for Paycor’s HR, Benefits Administration and ACA Software suite. This package helps users manage their company’s benefits packages, employee selections and all matters relating to compliance with Affordable Care Act legislation for businesses.

As you need an extra hand managing your company’s people, you’re likely to find a Paycor program that can help ease the burden. Plus, you’ll have the peace of mind that comes with knowing you’re taking much of the guesswork out of the process.

Pricing

Since Paycor offers several software options to handle different aspects of business administration, the overall cost of the platform will vary depending on what you choose to use. Plus, as with most HR software platforms, you may pay more or less depending on how many employees you manage within the system.

If you’re looking at Paycor’s payroll pricing, there are three tiers that cater to different-sized businesses. Each tier also includes an increasing number of tools and support, including assistance from a certified payroll professional with one-on-one counseling.

  • Paycor Basic starts at $99 per month and includes tax calculation and filing, reporting and an employee self-service portal in addition to full-service payroll management. With the Basic package, you’ll get 10 employee slots, with additional seats coming with an extra monthly charge depending on your needs.

  • Paycor Essential builds on what’s included in the Basic plan, incorporating employee self-service tools for wage garnishment and child support, HR templates for employee forms and enhanced analytics tools. This is in addition to full-service payroll tools, employee self-service tools for regular payroll matters and tax filing. This plan starts at $149 per month for 10 employees.

  • Paycor Complete provides everything in the Basic and Essential plans and adds in tailored assistance from payroll specialists, onboarding tools for new hires, 401(k) accounting support, tax filing and integrations with other common accounting tools. Paycor Complete Payroll costs $199 a month for up to 10 employees.

Features

The full Paycor suite is robust, covering just about every aspect of a small business’s HR and payroll needs. Currently, Paycor offers tools that can assist with recruiting and ATS, HR and benefits, learning management, time and attendance, payroll and tax and reporting and analytics.

Recruiting and ATS

  • Candidate application and interviewing pipeline beginning with candidacy to onboarding.

  • Real-time payroll analytics and reporting tools.

  • Identification of hiring tax credit opportunities and compliance support.

  • Employee onboarding tools.

HR and benefits

  • Unified employee record-keeping system.

  • Process and workflow creation.

  • Performance management tools.

  • Open enrollment portal for benefits.

  • Administrative task automation and coordination with benefits providers.

Learning management

  • Online learning portal that allows employees to log in from anywhere.

  • Manage, organize and track training modules and usage.

Time and management

  • Mobile punch-in support.

  • Employee scheduling software.

  • Unified record-keeping.

  • Customizable alerts and messaging.

  • Employee self-service tools.

Payroll and tax

  • Full-service payroll administration.

  • Tax compliance, calculation and withholding.

  • Real-time analytics and reporting.

  • Employee self-service capabilities.

Reporting and analytics

  •  Tools to help business owners track progress on goals.

  •  Customizable dashboards and report scheduling.

Reviews

Paycor is a large player in the HR and payroll software space, which means there are plenty of opinions from satisfied (and less than satisfied) customers. Most reviews are positive, although not without finding a few faults in the Paycor app environment.

Positive

  • Easy to use.

  • Easy to set up.

  • Robust scheduling tools for managing employees.

  • Very customizable.

Negative

  • Can be difficult to create customized shifts.

  • Time and attendance functions can be hard to navigate at first, but easier to set up with the one-on-one support Paycor offers.

Alternatives

When deciding which payroll and HR software is best for your business, it’s helpful to look at Paycor alternatives too. It’ll help you decide if you want to go forward with using Paycor, or, alternatively, point you in the right direction if you’ve concluded that Paycor isn’t quite the right fit.

Gusto

First up is Gusto, which is a relatively new payroll platform that’s been quickly adopted by many startups and technology-focused firms. The platform also enables you to manage benefits and some HR tasks along with payroll. There are three different levels of services for Gusto, so it’s likely you’ll find a nice, tailored fit for you — and you can always add on additional benefits management to make the platform even more custom.

Pricing for Gusto consists of a monthly base price plus a monthly per-employee cost and ranges from $39 per month plus $6 per employee to $149 per month plus $12 per employee. If you only employ contractors, you can skip the monthly base fee and pay only $6 per contractor per month.

QuickBooks Payroll

QuickBooks
Shop Now

on QuickBooks's website

QuickBooks Payroll

You’ll certainly know the name QuickBooks from the accounting software that’s popular with so many small-business owners. And to meet your payroll needs, there’s QuickBooks Payroll. This software integrates into QuickBooks Online seamlessly, enabling you to manage two of your biggest business operations tasks in one place. If you already use QuickBooks for your accounting needs, this is likely your best option for payroll.

Like Gusto, there are three different versions of QuickBooks Payroll — from $45 per month plus $4 per employee to $125 per month plus $10 per employee.

Gusto Payroll

Gusto
Shop Now

on Gusto's website

Paylocity

Our last Paycor competitor is Paylocity, which is similar to Paycor in many ways. Paylocity’s features extend beyond payroll to a host of HR-related tasks; however, the biggest difference between the two platforms is that Paylocity does not offer transparent pricing. Its pricing is quote-based, meaning you’ll have to reach out to its sales team directly to get a quote for your business.

A version of this article was first published on Fundera, a subsidiary of NerdWallet