Personal Loan vs. Auto Loan: What’s the Difference?

Auto loans are for vehicle purchases and tend to have lower rates than personal loans, which don't need to be secured by the car.

Nicole Dow
Jackie Veling
Kim Lowe
Updated

Although I write about personal loans for a living, I’ll admit I didn’t even consider one as an option when I financed a new car earlier this year.

Even with excellent credit, I knew it was unlikely that I’d qualify for an annual percentage rate under the 7.25% rate I was pre-approved for on an auto loan. And frankly, I also valued the one-stop-shopping experience of getting financing at the dealership.

While you can use a personal loan to finance a new or used car, you’ll typically save money by opting for an auto loan, which is a type of financing specifically for purchasing vehicles. On the other hand, a personal loan may make sense if you’re buying an older vehicle or purchasing from a private seller.

Let’s dig into the differences between these two financing options and when each one works best.

Personal loan vs. auto loan

Here’s a quick comparison of the rates, terms and other features of a personal loan compared to an auto loan.

Personal loans
Auto loans
Typical APR range
7%-36%.
4%-30%.
Typical repayment term
2-7 years.
2-7 years.
Secured?
Can be, but unsecured is more common.
Yes, by your vehicle.
Down payment?
No.
May be required.
Ownership
You own the car outright.
The auto lender has a lien on your vehicle until the loan is paid off.
Where to get
Banks, credit unions, online lenders.
Banks, credit unions, online lenders, auto dealerships.
Get started

Rates for personal loans vs. auto loans

With both types of loans, your credit profile, income and existing debts influence the annual percentage rate (APR) you receive. Having good or excellent credit (a score of 690 or higher), adequate income and little debt will help you qualify for the lowest rates.

Auto loan rates

Auto loan rates are typically lower than personal loan rates, because auto loans are secured by your vehicle and bring less risk to the lender. If you stop making payments on an auto loan, the lender can repossess your car to recoup its losses.

With an auto loan, the type of vehicle you buy also affects your rate. Loans for new cars often have lower APRs than those for used cars.

Here are the average auto loan rates, categorized by credit score band and type of vehicle purchase.

Credit score
Average APR, new car
Average APR, used car
Superprime: 781-850
4.41%
6.29%
Prime: 661-780
6.15%
8.81%
Nonprime: 601-660
9.71%
13.93%
Subprime: 501-600
13.52%
19.10%
Deep subprime: 300-500
16.11%
21.62%
Source: Experian Information Solutions, 2nd quarter 2026. Based on VantageScore credit scoring model.

Personal loan rates

Personal loans are usually unsecured, so rates are typically higher than auto loan rates. If you use a personal loan to pay for a car and stop making loan payments, the lender can’t take your vehicle, which makes this option a higher risk for lenders.

Here are the average rates for borrowers who pre-qualified for a personal loan through NerdWallet for the purpose of purchasing a vehicle.

Borrower credit rating
Score range
Estimated APR
Excellent
720-850
14.97%
Good
690-719
19.79%
Fair
630-689
24.16%
Bad
300-629
27.87%
Source: Average rates are based on aggregate, anonymized offer data from users who pre-qualified through NerdWallet in the last 30 days. Rates are estimates only and not specific to any lender.

When to get an auto loan instead of a personal loan

An auto loan is typically the more affordable way to finance a car purchase. Compared to personal loans, auto loans tend to have lower rates and are easier to qualify for because they’re secured by your vehicle.

Lower rates equal lower monthly payments and less interest spent over the life of the loan.

For example, let’s say you have good credit (a score from 690 to 719) and are able to get a 7% APR on a $25,000 auto loan with a repayment term of five years and no down payment.

Your monthly payment would be about $495. You’d pay a total of $4,702 in interest.

If you opted for a personal loan instead, it could come with a 20% APR if you have good credit.

A $25,000 personal loan with a 20% APR and a five-year repayment term would mean monthly payments of about $662, and you’d pay a total of $14,741 in interest. That’s about $167 more each month and over $10,000 more in total interest.

Another reason to choose an auto loan over a personal loan is for the convenience and perks of financing a car through the dealership. You get a streamlined shopping experience, and some dealers offer special financing perks, like cash rebates.

When to get a personal loan instead of an auto loan

While an auto loan is typically the best choice for financing a car purchase, you may have a difficult time qualifying for one depending on the type of vehicle you’re buying or the seller whom you’re getting it from.

My very first vehicle purchase was a 10-year-old car that I got from an auto auction — which I initially had to tow home, because it wasn’t running. I had the cash on hand for that purchase. But if I needed to borrow money to cover the cost, I likely wouldn’t have been able to qualify for an auto loan due to the age of the car and its condition.

You might have another unique situation in which a personal loan is more preferable. Here are a few reasons you might choose a personal loan over an auto loan.

  • You’re purchasing an older or high-mileage vehicle. If you’re trying to buy a car that is over 10 years old or has more than 100,000 miles, it might be difficult to get an auto loan. Auto lenders tend to have restrictions on the age and mileage of a financed vehicle.

  • You’re buying a car from a private party. Though it’s possible to get a private-party auto loan, not all lenders offer them. Also, the APRs are usually higher than traditional auto loans.

  • You want to avoid making a down payment. Some auto lenders and dealerships require you to make a down payment on the vehicle purchase. You won’t have to put down funds upfront for a personal loan, but you may need strong credit and income to qualify for a loan large enough to pay for the vehicle.

  • You would rather accept a higher rate to avoid using your car as collateral. Since an auto loan is secured by your vehicle, the lender has a lien on it until you pay off the loan. That means they can take your car if you don’t make payments.

  • You don’t want to purchase full insurance coverage for your vehicle. Auto loan lenders typically require full insurance coverage — which is usually defined as state-mandated liability insurance plus comprehensive and collision coverage — on your financed vehicle. You’ll still need to purchase the state-mandated liability coverage, but you can opt out of getting full coverage if you buy the car using a personal loan.

Steps to finance a vehicle purchase

The steps for getting personal and auto loans are similar and involve the following:

  1. Check your credit: Lenders will use your credit score to determine if you qualify and at what rate. Review your credit score and your credit reports for any errors before applying. You can get your credit score for free with NerdWallet. 

  2. Compare lenders: Before moving forward with a personal loan or auto loan, compare rates, terms and loan features. Estimate monthly payments using a personal loan calculator or an auto loan calculator, and determine what you can afford.

  3. Pre-qualify or get preapproved: Pre-qualifying for a personal loan will let you preview the rate and loan amount you could get without impacting your credit score. Pre-qualification is available through some auto lenders as well. Other auto lenders offer preapproval, which requires a hard credit pull, but it could result in a rate that’s closer to your final offer. A hard credit pull can cause your credit score to drop slightly.

  4. Formally apply and finalize your offer: The lender will likely conduct a hard credit pull when you formally apply, if it did not do so earlier. Read your loan contract carefully before signing to be sure you understand the terms.