Best Medicare Supplement Plans in New York 2024
Many, or all, of the products featured on this page are from our advertising partners who compensate us when you take certain actions on our website or click to take an action on their website. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own. Here is a list of our partners and here's how we make money.
There are nearly 1.9 million New York residents with Original Medicare, and Medicare Supplement Insurance companies compete for their business. Just two companies that sell policies in New York scored at the top of NerdWallet’s Medigap data-driven rankings based on pricing, complaint rates and more.
New York residents with Medicare Part A and Part B can purchase Medicare Supplement Insurance, or Medigap, to help cover certain out-of-pocket expenses like copays, coinsurance and deductibles left over after Medicare pays for covered services. Over 475,000 people in New York had Medigap coverage as of the end of 2022.
Here’s what you need to know about finding the best Medigap policy for you in New York.
Why trust NerdWallet
Compare the best Medigap plans in New York
Top-rated Medicare Supplement plans in New York
The federal government doesn’t calculate official star ratings for Medicare Supplement Insurance, so NerdWallet developed our own data-driven ratings. Below are companies in New York that scored best on NerdWallet’s 2024 Medigap rubric. (See our ratings methodology for more on how we evaluate Medicare Supplement Insurance companies.)
5-star plans (NerdWallet rating)
4.5-star plans (NerdWallet rating)
Anthem also scores well on NerdWallet’s Medigap rankings with 4 out of 5 stars in 2024, but the company is no longer accepting new Medicare Supplement Insurance members in New York.
Medicare Supplement Insurance prices in New York
Here are the prices for Medigap Plan G and Plan N, the most popular plans available for new Medicare members, from the companies that sell policies in New York and scored 4 stars or better on NerdWallet’s Medigap rubric.
The table below shows price estimates for a 65-year-old female nonsmoker in New York City as filed with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (Note: Some Medigap prices may be higher for males.)
Insurance company | Plan G monthly premiums | Plan N monthly premiums |
|---|---|---|
AARP/UnitedHealthcare | $306. | $241. |
Mutual of Omaha | $476. | Not offered. |
For reference, here are the lowest premiums available from any company for the two plans in New York City, according to the Medicare plan finding tool:
Medigap Plan G: $302 per month.
Medigap Plan N: $220 per month.
From our Nerds: Who offers the best Medicare Supplement plans in New York?
"Two Medicare Supplement Insurance companies selling policies in New York scored at least 4 out of 5 stars on NerdWallet’s 2024 Medigap rubric: AARP/UnitedHealthcare and Mutual of Omaha. That’s based on our analysis of companies’ premiums, discounts, complaint rates, online quote availability and more."
Note: We can’t review every Medigap company, and a company not among our top rankings might be a great fit for you. It’s a good idea to do your research, compare multiple quotes and consider working with a licensed insurance agent for more personalized recommendations.
— Alex Rosenberg, lead writer covering Medicare
Largest Medicare Supplement Insurance companies in New York
The government regulates Medigap plans, but private insurance companies sell them. Here are the five Medicare Supplement Insurance companies with the most members in New York as of the end of 2022:
Insurance company | Share of New York Medigap members |
|---|---|
74.5%. | |
10.8%. | |
3. Globe Life Insurance Company of New York | 7.2%. |
4. Excellus BlueCross BlueShield* | 2.6%. |
5. Humana | 1.7%. |
*Anthem and Excellus are independent Blue Cross Blue Shield companies serving different portions of the state. | |
Most popular Medigap plan types in New York
There are 10 standard Medigap plan types available in New York (Plan C and Plan F aren’t available for new Medicare members). However, over 87% of Medigap members in New York are in one of the three most popular types.
Here are New York’s top three most popular Medicare Supplement Insurance plan types:
45% have Medigap Plan F — the most comprehensive coverage of any Medigap plan.
28% have Medigap Plan N — a plan with lower premiums but higher copays.
14% have Medigap Plan G — the highest-coverage option available to new Medicare members.
Medigap Plan F isn’t available to Medicare beneficiaries who became eligible for Medicare on or after Jan. 1, 2020. Medigap Plan G is the most similar option available to all Medicare beneficiaries.
Medicare resources in New York
Health Insurance Information, Counseling, and Assistance Programs (HIICAP): Provides information and free, confidential counseling about Medicare, related health insurance subjects and health care affordability for Medicare beneficiaries.
New York Office for the Aging: Administers programs and services to help older adults live independently in the community for as long as possible.
Find the right Medicare Supplement Insurance plan
Because Medigap plans are standardized, you can get precisely the same Medicare benefits from any company offering the plan. So when you shop, keep these considerations in mind to find the best policy to fit your needs:
Is your preferred plan available? Health insurance companies don’t always sell every plan, so check who sells the plan you want to buy in your area.
What are the premiums? Prices for the same plan can vary between companies, so check to find the most competitive rates.
Will your premiums change over time? Most policies cost more as you age, but some companies offer policies that let you lock in a price when you sign up.
Are there extras? Medigap plans’ core benefits are standardized, but in certain cases, some companies include such perks as discount programs or gym memberships.
Medicare Supplement Insurance ratings methodology
NerdWallet’s Medicare Supplement Insurance (Medigap) ratings are based on pricing, discounts, plan types offered, complaint data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, consumer experience, additional perks and benefits, and more. To calculate each health insurance company's rating, we adjusted the scores to a curved 5-point scale, rounded to the nearest half star.
NerdWallet reviewed 15 Medicare Supplement Insurance companies based on highest enrollment and greatest online search volume. At the national level, our scored reviews include companies covering about two-thirds of all Medigap beneficiaries. At the state level, our research includes at least one of the two largest Medigap insurance companies in 48 of the 50 states, plus Washington, D.C.
These ratings are a guide, but we encourage you to shop around and compare several insurance quotes to find the best coverage and rate for you. NerdWallet does not receive compensation for any reviews. Read our editorial guidelines and full ratings methodology for Medicare Supplement Insurance.
Insurer complaints methodology
We examined complaints received by state insurance regulators and reported to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. To assess how insurers compare to one another, the NAIC calculates a complaint index each year for each subsidiary, measuring its share of total complaints relative to its size, or share of total premiums in the industry. To evaluate a company’s complaint history, we calculated a similar index for each insurance company, weighted by market shares of each subsidiary. We score companies based on this index of how many complaints the company receives relative to its market share. NerdWallet conducts its data analysis and reaches conclusions independently and without the endorsement of the NAIC.
This roundup includes only insurance companies that sell Medicare Supplement Insurance in New York.
