Apple is touting its recently launched Apple Card as another in a long line of innovations, claiming it “completely rethinks everything about the credit card." But that’s a bit of an overstatement.
While the Apple Card does boast some compelling attributes, perhaps the most innovative thing about it is that it combines several hard-to-find — but not unprecedented — features into a single package.
“We need to keep in mind that this is simply a credit card," says Brian Riley, director of the credit advisory service for Mercator Advisory Group, a payments and banking industry consulting group, via email. Noting that the Apple Card will be competing against some well-established issuers, including Chase and American Express, he says it will be “a case study in loyalty. Will the masses follow Apple?"
If you’re tempted to take the Apple Card plunge, here’s how to separate the helpful features from the hype.
» MORE: Should you get the Apple Card?
No, the Apple Card doesn’t ‘completely rethink everything’
The Apple Card doesn’t so much break new ground as consolidate it.
Unlike many other cash-back credit cards, this one is clearly designed for mobile-first users. In fact, the only way you can apply for the Apple Card is via an eligible iPhone, which is unique (if also a potential roadblock).
The Apple Card doesn’t so much break new ground as consolidate it.
“As with all Apple products, there is indeed an elegance to it," Riley says.
But virtually any credit card can be added to a mobile wallet and used the same way.
The Apple Card does incentivize the use of a mobile wallet, earning the following rewards:
|3% cash back||• Apple Pay purchases made directly with Apple (including Apple stores, within the App Store and for Apple services).
• Uber and Uber Eats purchases via Apple Pay.
• Walgreens and Duane Reade purchases via Apple Pay.
• In-store T-Mobile purchases via Apple Pay.
• Nike purchases via Apple Pay (in U.S. stores, via Nike.com and on Nike apps). Apple Pay is not available on Nike.com via desktop, but Apple notes it is "coming soon."
|2% cash back||All other purchases made via Apple Pay.|
|1% cash back||All purchases made with the physical Apple Card.|
But many Apple Card competitors earn similar rates or higher without requiring that you use a mobile wallet to get them.
And about that physical, “laser-etched titanium" card, which you must request separately, by the way? Apple has gone to great and hilarious lengths to explain how to care for it, but the best way to take care of it — and yourself — is to simply not carry it around at all. Its rewards rate just isn’t competitive today.
When it comes to fees, the Apple Card trumpets its lack of them — but you can find any number of cash-back cards that similarly charge neither an annual fee nor any “over-the-limit" fees, which have been extinct for years. More interesting is the Apple Card’s lack of foreign transaction fees or late fees. It’s harder (though not impossible) to find cash-back cards that don’t charge a fee for purchases abroad, and though other cards already waive late fees, typically those products don’t earn rewards.
So what is new about the Apple Card?
The Apple Card did rethink — that is, it opted against — offering a sign-up bonus, a 0% intro APR period or the ability to add authorized users, all of which are common features of its competitors.
But it’s certainly not all bad news. The Apple Card does bring some truly fresh offerings to the table:
- See your credit limit and APR before committing to the card. If approved for the card, you can decide — based on the credit limit and APR you’re offered — whether you want to accept the deal. Apple says you’ll have up to 30 days to make your decision and that “your credit score is not affected until after you accept." You’ll be hard-pressed to find another card that shows you this information before pulling your credit.
- Access 24/7 text-message-based customer support. Round-the-clock customer service isn’t new, but carrying on a conversation with the issuer via text is novel, and ideal if you loathe phone calls and long hold times. (You can also call through the iPhone Wallet app.)
- Use Apple Maps to help clarify your purchases. You can tap on individual charges you make with the card to pinpoint that merchant’s location on your iPhone’s Apple Maps app.
And what is just rare or interesting?
The Apple Card also offers some features that, while not unheard of, are still nice to have and not a given:
- Instant access to your card upon approval. Start making purchases immediately, with no need to wait days before receiving a physical card in the mail. Instant credit access is uncommon, but not new.
- Ability to accrue (and spend) rewards in real time. There’s no minimum redemption amount and no waiting until the billing cycle is over to access your stash. These features are welcome, but available elsewhere.
- A billing cycle that’s always at the end of the calendar month. Apple calls this a payment schedule “based on common sense," and it can certainly make it easier to keep track of when your bill is due. But other issuers already allow you to set your own billing date.
- Access to financial tools to help you break down and categorize your spending. Helpful, but available via many other credit cards and third-party sites, NerdWallet included. (One drawback: Downloading your transaction history to Mint or similar financial apps is not supported.)
- Instant card replacement: If you suspect your Apple Card might have been compromised, you can generate a new card number and invalidate your old one, all within the Wallet app. This is nifty and can save time, but other cards offer free overnight card replacement and/or the ability to “freeze" or “lock" a misplaced card.
The Apple Card claims to take security a step further, instituting additional privacy measures so that Apple can’t tell where you shopped, what you bought or how much you spent. (Apple notes that Goldman Sachs, on the other hand, does have access to your data.)
Are its interest rates ‘among the lowest in the industry’?
When the Apple Card debuted in August 2019, Apple noted that it would have a variable APR of 12.99% to 23.99% based on creditworthiness.
The low end of that range is better than average — and better than what many other cash-back credit cards offer. But only those with excellent credit are likely to qualify for that rate.
Although the low end of the Apple Card’s APR range is better than average — and better than what many other cash-back credit cards offer — only those with excellent credit are likely to qualify for that rate.
And you might be able to do even better still with a credit union credit card.
It’s worth noting that the Apple Card app has some terrific visual incentives to help you understand how much credit card interest you’re potentially accruing if you don’t pay your bill in full every month. The “Choose Amount" dial goes from red to green as it displays an estimate of the interest you’ll pay, based on the payment amount you choose.
There’s also a longer-than-average grace period that lasts until the end of that month’s billing cycle, rather than the typical 21-day window, giving you some extra time to pay your bill before you start accumulating interest on your balance.
‘Created by Apple, not a bank’?
Apple obviously had a big hand in developing this product. But the card is still issued by Goldman Sachs, an investment bank. And it’s Goldman Sachs that will review your application, along with your credit scores, credit report and the income you claim on your application to decide whether you will be approved for the card.
It’s Goldman Sachs, not Apple, that will review your application — including your credit scores, credit report and the income you claim — to determine whether you will be approved.
That kind of underwriting is standard for the vast majority of credit cards on the market. A handful of so-called “alternative credit cards" can evaluate creditworthiness beyond credit scores and history — but the Apple Card isn’t one of them.