Best Cities for Cheap Car Insurance

Auto Insurance, Insurance
shutterstock_24835033 (2)

There are many factors that influence car insurance rates. A recent study by InsuranceQuotes.com finds that buying car insurance in December is cheaper than buying it in any other month. Timing affects car insurance rates, but location is a strong determinant as well. Weather, crime rates and traffic congestion are just some of the factors that might influence your annual car insurance premium. But how much does location actually matter? NerdWallet crunched the numbers to find which of the largest U.S. cities offers cheap car insurance.

Key Findings:

  • Six of the top ten cities were in North Carolina
  • North Carolina has driver-friendly car insurance laws

If you are looking for the country’s best car insurance rates, you should move to North Carolina. Six of the ten cheapest cities for car insurance were in North Carolina. North Carolina enjoys pleasant weather, but it also has car insurance laws conducive to low prices. Unlike U.S.’s worst cities for car insurance rates, North Carolina does not have no-fault car insurance laws.

Here are the best cities for car insurance in the U.S:

(Interested in your area’s car insurance costs? Check out NerdWallet’s car insurance tool here.)

Best Cities for Car Insurance

1. Winston-Salem, North Carolina

Average car insurance premium: $969.10

Winston-Salem tops our list with average premiums of $969.10. The city is home to Wake Forest University and R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company as well. Winston-Salem is a point in the Piedmont Triad, a region known for its contribution to culture and education. It is also a hub for transportation and manufacturing. Winston-Salem is classified as a sub-tropical area and the temperature averages a high of 51 degrees in the winter and 89 degrees in the summer.

2. Greensboro, North Carolina

Annual car insurance premium: $1,089.58

Greensboro is another city in the Piedmont Triad. It is also the city with the second cheapest annual car insurance premiums on our list. Greensboro is a transportation hub. It is the home of Piedmont Triad International Airport. Greensboro also has Amtrak trains that connect to other major U.S. cities such as New York and New Orleans.

The city also benefits from state policies aimed at curbing insurance fraud. Widespread insurance fraud can raise average premiums. North Carolina offers a toll-free hotline within North Carolina so that you can report suspected insurance fraud: (888) 680-7684).

3. Raleigh, North Carolina

Average Car Insurance premium: $1,098.48

Raleigh a city in North Carolina’s research triangle and is home to North Carolina State University. Raleigh has an extensive public transportation system, which has 43 fixed bus routes. North Carolina State University also runs its own bus line, which helps alleviate congestion.

Large numbers of uninsured drivers can increase car insurance rates for all drivers. North Carolina has one of the lowest rates of uninsured motorists in the country, at just 8 percent.

4. Durham, North Carolina

Average car insurance premium: $1,100.50

Another vertex of the Research Triangle, Durham, also makes the list. Durham is home to Duke University and North Carolina Central University. Commuters traveling to other Research Triangle cities can take Triangle Transit, a commuter bus that also helps alleviate the area’s congestion. It is warm most of the year and Durham only averages 6.8 inches of snow a year.

5. Charlotte, North Carolina

Average car insurance premium: $1,123.09

Charlotte is blessed with good weather, which helps contribute to the city’s low car insurance rates. It also rarely snows in Charlotte, averaging around just six inches of snow a year.  The Charlotte Area Transit System (CATS) operates light rail and bus systems, which city planners hope to extend to the University of North Carolina-Charlotte campus.

6. Boise, Idaho

Average car insurance premium: $1,221.65

Boise’s low crime rate and lack of congestion help keep its car insurance rates low. Its average commute time is 20 minutes, which is much lower than the national average. Companies such as Albertsons and Bodybuilding.com have their headquarters in Boise. The city has a 5.9 percent unemployment rate, which helps keep Boise’s average car insurance premium low.

7. Rochester, New York

Average car insurance in Rochester: $1,249.26

Rochester is often touted a good city to raise a family. It is home to world-class universities, most notably the University of Rochester and the Rochester Institute of Technology. The city is also home to large companies such as Eastman Kodak and Bausch and Lomb, which help keep employment levels at reasonable rates.

Large numbers of uninsured drivers can increase a city’s average car insurance premium, but the New York Automobile Insurance Plan helps high-risk drivers find insurance. Drivers can apply for insurance through NYAIP and take a course to automatically lower their insurance rates.

8. Fayetteville, North Carolina
Average car insurance premium: $1,294.80

Fayetteville is home to Fort Bragg, a major army installation. Fort Bragg is the main economic driver in Fayetteville and as such Fayetteville boasts a relatively low unemployment rate.

Fayetteville also benefits from North Carolina’s Safe Driver Incentive Plan. The program promotes safe driving by increasing insurance costs for unsafe drivers. For example, a moving violation will increase a driver’s premium by 30 percent.

9. Spokane, Washington 

Average car insurance premium: $1,307.68

In Washington, high-risk drivers are encouraged to enroll in the Washington Automobile Insurance Plan (WAIP). The WAIP is a part of the Western Association of Automobile Insurance Plans (WAAIP), a group that allows insurance companies to share the risk of high-risk drivers.  High-risk drivers often have trouble finding insurance, but through WAIP, they are can purchase insurance, albeit at a much higher price. Interested drivers can apply for car insurance through the WAAIP website.

10.  Montgomery, Alabama

Average car insurance premium: $1,375.82

Montgomery is home to many government agencies and is the home of Maxwell Air Force Base. Many insurance companies offer military discounts. USAA, which only accepts military personnel and their family as members, is often rated highly for its service and price.

What can be done about insurance rates?

Although residents of Winston-Salem, Boise and Rochester pay reasonable car insurance premiums, we have found that on average drivers overpay $368 for car insurance every year. No matter where you live, you should compare insurance rates and seek relevant discounts to truly minimize your car insurance payments.

NerdWallet also found the cities with the most expensive car insurance premiums.Winston-Salemvia Shutterstock

Rank City State Population Average Car Insurance Premium
1 Winston-Salem NC 232,397 $969.10
2 Greensboro NC 273,419 $1,089.58
3 Raleigh NC 416,126 $1,098.48
4 Durham NC 233,210 $1,100.50
5 Charlotte NC 751,074 $1,123.09
6 Boise City ID 210,151 $1,221.65
7 Rochester NY 210,850 $1,249.26
8 Fayetteville NC 203,922 $1,294.80
9 Spokane WA 210,107 $1,307.68
10 Montgomery AL 213,132 $1,375.82
11 Des Moines IA 206,577 $1,420.07
12 Birmingham AL 211,458 $1,429.36
13 Albuquerque NM 552,801 $1,442.01
14 Anchorage AK 295,570 $1,449.39
15 Mobile AL 194,887 $1,470.68
16 San Diego CA 1,326,183 $1,474.71
17 Chesapeake VA 225,050 $1,479.11
18 San Jose CA 967,478 $1,483.83
19 Madison WI 236,889 $1,490.36
20 Chula Vista CA 247,514 $1,490.56
21 Virginia Beach VA 442,707 $1,494.24
22 Irvine CA 215,511 $1,498.10
23 Fremont CA 216,912 $1,502.47
24 Huntington Beach CA 192,868 $1,510.83
25 Pittsburgh PA 307,498 $1,514.27
26 Oxnard CA 199,917 $1,519.11
27 Fort Wayne IN 258,803 $1,532.76
28 Bakersfield CA 352,429 $1,560.93
29 Tallahassee FL 182,955 $1,573.02
30 Norfolk VA 242,628 $1,591.95

Methodology

To find the average car insurance rates of the 125 largest cities in the United States, we used the profile of a 26-year-old male without any history of accidents, insuring a 2012 Toyota Camry with extended coverage (100/300/50 with a 500 deductible). In calculating averages for each city, we only used zip codes within city limits and not in the city’s metro area.