The bottom line: Intelligent Portfolios is unique in charging no management fee, but portfolios tend to hold a larger cash allocation than other robo-advisors.
Best Robo-Advisor for Portfolio Options
Schwab Intelligent Portfolios®
no promotion available at this time
Pros & Cons
- No management fee.
- Wide ETF selection.
- Automatic rebalancing.
- Customizable portfolio.
- High account minimum.
- Large cash allocation.
- Tax-loss harvesting only available on balances of $50,000 or more.
Compare to Other Advisors
Varies by advisor
$100 and up
per month (free initial consultation)
no promotion available at this time
no promotion available at this time
one year of financial planning (requires annual payment upfront)
Get more smart money moves — straight to your inbox
Become a NerdWallet member, and we’ll send you tailored articles we think you’ll love.
Charles Schwab's online advisor service, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios, offers two options to investors. The base service, Intelligent Portfolios, is a robo-advisor that requires a $5,000 minimum investment and charges no advisory fee. Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium, an online financial planning service, provides clients with unlimited access to certified financial planners for a $25,000 minimum balance and $30 monthly fee. The premium offering also charges a $300 one-time planning fee.
Schwab Intelligent Portfolios is best for:
Access to certified financial planners (at the Premium tier).
High account balances.
Schwab Intelligent Portfolios at a glance
$5,000 for Schwab Intelligent Portfolios; $25,000 for Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium.
Account management fee
$0 for Schwab Intelligent Portfolios; $30/month for Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium.
Investment expense ratios
No transfer fees, but clients pay ETF expense ratios.
81 different portfolios built from 53 ETFs across 10 different fund families (Schwab and third party), including up to 20 asset classes. Offers Global, U.S. Focused and Income Focused portfolios.
Socially responsible portfolio option
Clients can exclude up to three ETFs.
Tax-loss harvesting is free with a $50,000 minimum balance.
Free on all accounts.
Human advisor option
Clients have 24/7 access to advisors with Series 7/63 or 7/66 licenses, though these advisors do not give personalized investment advice.
Premium clients have unlimited access to CFPs and can receive a dedicated advisor for no extra charge if requested.
Savings account/cash management account option
Savings account through Schwab generally offers an interest rate of 0.15%.
Customer support options (includes website transparency)
Phone and live chat support 24/7.
Where Schwab Intelligent Portfolios shines
Free management: Schwab's base service, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios, charges no management fees, commissions or account fees. This is rare among robo-advisors, which make money mostly from management fees.
However, it isn't exactly a case of charity — customers still pay the expense ratios on the investments used in their portfolios, and many of those are Schwab funds. The company also takes a cut of the interest earned on the uninvested cash in portfolios (more about this below). But even factoring those in, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios is a value.
Flat fee for Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium: The free management goes away if you opt for Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium, the company's hybrid advisor that offers the same portfolio options as the free service, alongside unlimited access to certified financial planners. Premium costs $30 a month (billed as $90 quarterly) and requires a balance of $25,000 or more. It also charges a one-time $300 planning fee.
Most robo-advisors — and human financial advisors — charge an annual fee calculated as a percentage of assets under management. To compare costs, it's important to look at how much Schwab's flat fee costs as a percentage of your balance. Like most flat fees, Schwab's pricing is ideal for investors with higher balances, who seem to be the target of the service.
Here's the percentage of assets under management you'll pay for Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium at sample portfolio balances:
$30/month as a percentage of assets per year
For context, compare these numbers with the 0.30% charged by Vanguard Personal Advisor Services, the 0.40% fee for Betterment Premium — Betterment's hybrid offering that also offers unlimited phone access to financial advisors — and the 0.89% charged by Personal Capital.
As you can see, investors who deposit Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium's minimum of $25,000 will get burned, while those who exceed $125,000 will enjoy very competitive costs when compared with other services. It gets almost unheard-of cheap as account balances climb into the high six figures.
Unlimited access to a team of CFPs: That flat fee for Premium comes with a lot of value in the form of access to a team of certified financial planners. A lot of people will happily dole out financial advice, but quality matters — these advisors have specialized training and must abide by a code of ethics. Meetings are held via phone, chat, email or video conference.
Clients who opt in to the premium service receive a written financial plan and get access to interactive planning tools where they can update assumptions and change their plans. While the service doesn't initially pair clients with a dedicated advisor, clients can schedule time with the same advisor if they wish.
Investment scope: Schwab handily delivers on the diversification promise. It draws from 53 exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, which enables it to offer exposure to over 20 asset classes. The company says the weighted average operating expense ratio of portfolios built by the service is 0.11%. These portfolios are used in both the free and Premium offerings.
Ability to customize: Like other automatic advisory services, Schwab cooks up a customized portfolio based on the answers to questions that get at an investor’s goals, time horizon and risk profile. Investors can tweak the allocation in Schwab's recommended model by picking as many as three ETFs to remove and Schwab will replace it with an alternative. For example, if you don’t like the foreign-market ETF chosen for your portfolio, Schwab’s feature lets you punt it from your portfolio in favor of another from the list.
Customers can have as many as 10 different types of Intelligent Portfolios accounts (so long as there's $5,000 in each account), customizing each with a different goal and strategy.
Financial planning tools: Speaking of goals, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium offers a variety of tools to help you set and reach your financial goals. A scenario-planning tool called the Play Zone stands out: It allows you to change assumptions about your finances and lifestyle — things like when you plan to retire, how much you're saving and lifestyle choices — to see the potential impact on reaching your goal. Other tools assist with college planning, preparing for unexpected expenses and goal tracking.
Where Schwab Intelligent Portfolios falls short
One-time planning fee for premium service: Schwab is the only online advisor we review that charges an upfront fee when opening a Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium account, which it calls a "one-time planning fee." It's a steep $300, and should be factored in when you compare the cost of services.
Revisiting the table above, that extra $300 nearly doubles the cost of Schwab's premium service for the first year:
$30/month + $300 as a percentage of assets in first year
Note that this fee is only applied to Premium accounts; it doesn't apply to basic Schwab Intelligent Portfolios accounts.
Large cash position in portfolios: The biggest criticism of Schwab Intelligent Portfolios’ strategy is that it allocates a good percentage of money to cash — a minimum of 6% all the way up to nearly 30% of total portfolio holdings, the latter of which makes sense for those at the conservative end of the risk spectrum. According to Schwab, most Intelligent Portfolios clients hold from 6% to 10% in cash. But even that may even be too cash-heavy for some investors.
Sitting on do-nothing cash may be good for investors who aren't disciplined about deploying their cash reserves, especially when the market is in a down cycle. But those who have other plans for their cash and who desire a completely invested portfolio service may be turned off by this unavoidable cash allocation.
Limited tax-loss strategy: Tax-loss harvesting is one of the selling points of having a robo-advisor manage your portfolio. It’s a complicated task of selling loser investments in a taxable account to offset taxes on any gains. It's particularly valuable for investors in the higher income tax brackets. The service is only available to clients who opt into the feature and have a minimum of $50,000 in their taxable account. Keep that in mind if it's a must-have feature on your wish list.
Is Schwab Intelligent Portfolios right for you?
Schwab Intelligent Portfolios has all the characteristics of an ideal robo-advisor: The company has a strong reputation, its portfolios feature low-cost ETFs and offers all this with an ongoing $0 management fee. Investors who have $25,000 or more and want access to financial planners can upgrade to Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium for $30 a month and a one-time $300 planning fee.
We’re not fans of the high cash allocation, especially for younger investors, and the one-time planning fee for premium is tough to swallow. We would also like to see tax-loss harvesting made available for any customers with taxable accounts, not just those with $50,000 or more. But Schwab is a solid choice for savers taking their first foray into robo-advisor managed accounts. Low-balance investors may want to stick with the basic service, then consider premium when their balance tops $125,000.
Disclosure: The author held no positions in the aforementioned securities at the original time of publication.
Dayana Yochim contributed to this review.
How do we review financial advisors? Here’s our methodology.
NerdWallet’s comprehensive review process evaluates and ranks the largest U.S. brokers by assets under management, along with emerging industry players, using a multifaceted and iterative approach. Our aim is to provide an independent assessment of providers to help arm you with information to make sound, informed judgments on which ones will best meet your needs.
DATA COLLECTION AND REVIEW PROCESS
We collect data directly from providers, and conduct firsthand testing and observation through provider demonstrations. Our process starts by sending detailed questionnaires to providers to complete. The questionnaires are structured to equally elicit both favorable and unfavorable responses from providers. They are not designed or prepared to produce any predetermined results. The questionnaire answers, combined with product demonstrations, interviews of personnel at the providers and our specialists’ hands-on research, fuel our proprietary assessment process that scores each provider’s performance across more than 20 factors. The final output produces star ratings from poor (one star) to excellent (five stars). Ratings are rounded to the nearest half-star.
Evaluations vary by provider type, but in each case are based upon the weighted averages of factors that include but are not limited to: advisory and account fees, account minimums and types, investment selection, investment expense ratios, trading costs, access to human financial advisors, educational resources and tools, rebalancing and tax minimization options, and customer support including branch access, user-facing technology and mobile platforms.
Each factor can involve evaluating various sub-factors. For instance, when gauging the investment selections offered by robo-advisors, 80% of the score is based on the potential for diversification (how well-diversified a resulting portfolio of investments could be) combined with the availability of specialty portfolios and level of customization for investors. Expense ratios form an additional 10% of the score, and low or no management fee the remaining 10%.
The weighting of each factor is based on our team’s assessment of which features are the most important to consumers and which ones impact the consumer experience in the most meaningful way. The factors considered, and how those factors are weighted, change depending upon the category of providers reviewed.
Writers and editors conduct our broker reviews on an annual basis but continually make updates throughout the year. We maintain frequent contact with providers and highlight any changes in offerings.
THE REVIEW TEAM
The review team comprises seasoned writers, researchers and editors who cover stocks, bonds, mutual funds, index funds, exchange-traded funds, alternative investments, socially responsible investing, financial advisors, retirement and investment strategy on a daily basis. In addition to NerdWallet, the work of our team members has been published in The New York Times, The Washington Post, Forbes, USA Today, Bloomberg News, Nasdaq, MSN, MarketWatch, Yahoo! Finance and other national and regional media outlets.
The combined expertise of our Investing team is infused into our review process to ensure thoughtful evaluations of provider products and services from the customer perspective. Our writers and editors combine to have more than 70 years of deep experience in finance, ranging from a former Wall Street Journal reporter to a former senior financial advisor at Merrill Lynch.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
While NerdWallet does have partnerships with many of the reviewed providers, we manage potential conflicts of interest by maintaining a wall between our content and business operations. This wall is designed to prevent our writers and the review process from being influenced or impacted by our business partnerships. This way, all reviews can provide an unbiased review that serves the interests of our users. For more information, see NerdWallet’s editorial guidelines.