5 Things to Know About the Best Buy Credit Card

If you're a techie and Best Buy is your first stop for new electronics, this credit card could make sense. But it lacks flexibility.
Erin Hurd, Paul SoucySep 10, 2021
5 Things to Know About the Best Buy Credit Card

Many or all of the products featured here are from our partners who compensate us. This may influence which products we write about and where and how the product appears on a page. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own. Here is a list of our partners and here's how we make money.

Electronics superstore Best Buy offers two co-branded store cards that earn rewards for shopping with the retailer. Carrying one of them might make sense if you do the bulk of your electronics shopping there, especially given how expensive devices like smartphones, HDTVs and laptops can be — and how quickly they grow obsolete.

But rewards are redeemable only at Best Buy, and while the cards offer deferred-interest financing for certain purchases, a true 0% intro APR offer would be a safer bet in most cases. Plenty of other rewards credit cards offer more versatile and flexible incentives.

Here are five things to know about the Best Buy credit card.

1. There are two basic Best Buy credit cards

You can apply in-store or online for a Best Buy credit card, but the process is a bit opaque. Essentially, there are two basic versions:

My Best Buy Credit Card. This is a "closed-loop" store card, meaning it's accepted only at Best Buy and BestBuy.com. There is no annual fee.

My Best Buy Visa. This is an "open-loop" credit card, accepted anywhere that takes Visa. This card comes in two versions, with the only significant difference being the annual fee. When you submit your application, Best Buy will tell you which one you've been approved for:

  • Gold. This version has an annual fee of $59.

  • Platinum. This version has no annual fee.

According to Best Buy, when you apply for a card, you are first considered for the My Best Buy Visa Platinum (open-loop, no annual fee). If you don't qualify, you're then considered for, in order, the My Best Buy Credit Card (store card) and finally the My Best Buy Visa Gold (with annual fee).

In other words, you won't have any control over which version you get approved for.

2. Rewards rates are decent, but redemption is clunky

Carrying any of these credit cards means joining the My Best Buy shopper loyalty program, as rewards are earned as points in that program. You then turn those points into Best Buy rewards certificates: Every 250 points earns you a $5 reward certificate, giving the points an effective value of 2 cents apiece. (You'll need at least 250 points to redeem.)

For shopping at Best Buy, the rewards offerings are the same on either card version. You'll get:

  • 5% back on all purchases at Best Buy (2.5 points per $1 spent).

  • Flexible financing options (more on that below).

But the Visa version of the card goes a lot further. Beyond 5% back at Best Buy, you'll also earn:

  • 3% back on gas purchases (1.5 points per $1 spent).

  • 2% back on dining and grocery purchases (1 point per $1 spent).

  • 1% back on other everyday purchases (1 point per $2 spent).

Again, every 250 points will earn you a $5 reward certificate. You’ll receive a certificate automatically to your inbox every time you reach 250 points, unless you choose to manually change this setting.

Nerdy tip: For either card, you'll increase your rate at Best Buy to 6% back (3 points per $1 spent) if you're a My Best Buy Elite Plus member. (The program has three levels; Elite Plus is the highest, and you'll reach that by spending $3,500 in a calendar year.)

3. Deferred interest may be an option … but it comes with potential risk

The Best Buy cards advertise occasional "no interest if paid in full" offers (aka, "deferred interest" offers), ranging between six and 36 months, which might sound attractive. But it's important to understand what deferred interest means.

With such an offer, interest is not waived, as it would be with a true 0% intro APR promotion. Instead, a deferred-interest offer merely sets aside that interest until later.

If you pay off your purchase by the end of the deferred-interest period, you're fine. But if you carry a balance past the end of the period — even a few dollars — you'll be charged the card's full ongoing interest rate on your entire purchase, going back to the day you made it. And the interest rate on Best Buy credit cards is high: 25.24% as of July 2020.

If you need to finance a large purchase and avoiding interest is your primary aim, consider instead credit cards with a true 0% APR offer.

4. You’ll get an incentive for opening the card

Like many store credit cards, Best Buy offers a one-time incentive for new cardholders.

A common offer is to receive a total 10% back in Best Buy points on your first day of purchases when you are approved for the card. That means if you’re spending $2,000 on your first Best Buy credit card purchase, you’ll get 10,000 points. That’s equal to $200 in Best Buy rewards certificates. Unlike many credit cards, you won’t have to spend a certain amount on purchases on your new card before you receive the bonus.

In lieu of the one-time 10% back option, you can also choose flexible financing (aka, deferred interest offers).

5. If you’re not a die-hard Best Buy shopper, you can do better

If you're regularly spending enough at Best Buy to earn your way into an elite membership level, then a Best Buy credit card might make sense, especially because you'd likely be shopping at the store enough that you could regularly cash in your rewards.

But with its $59 annual fee, the My Best Buy Visa Gold is not a good deal. Even if you were an Elite Plus member, you would have to spend nearly $1,000 at Best Buy before your rewards would make up for the annual fee. If you're considering a Best Buy credit card, you'd want either the My Best Buy Credit Card (store card) or the My Best Buy Visa Platinum.

But, again, you don't have control over which card you'll be approved for.

For most people, a general rewards credit card that's not tied to any specific retailer will be a better and more flexible option. Check out NerdWallet's list of best rewards credit cards for options.

Information related to the My Best Buy Credit Card and My Best Buy Visa has been collected by NerdWallet and has not been reviewed or provided by the issuer of these cards. 

Get more smart money moves – straight to your inbox
Sign up and we’ll send you Nerdy articles about the money topics that matter most to you along with other ways to help you get more from your money.