Advertiser Disclosure

NerdWallet’s Auto Insurance Reviews for 2021

Looking for auto insurance reviews? We've researched all the top car insurance companies and compiled the results here.
Sept. 14, 2021
Auto Insurance, Insurance
Many or all of the products featured here are from our partners who compensate us. This may influence which products we write about and where and how the product appears on a page. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own.

If you’re looking for auto insurance reviews, you’ve come to the right place. NerdWallet has researched policy options, consumer complaint data, customer satisfaction ratings, financial stability and more for the country’s top car insurance companies. Browse our reviews below based on what kind of auto insurance company you need.

Not sure where to start? Geico was NerdWallet’s pick for the Best Budget Auto Insurance of 2021.

 


Mainstream auto insurance reviews


Most insurers fall into this category, offering traditional auto insurance and catering to the majority of drivers. These companies set rates based on driving history, age, location, and, in most states, gender and credit history. But each auto insurer values your personal factors differently, so you can get widely different rates from one to the next.

21ST CENTURY

ALLSTATE

AMERICAN FAMILY

AMERIPRISE

AMICA

AUTO-OWNERS

CLEARCOVER

COUNTRY FINANCIAL

ELEPHANT

ENCOMPASS

ERIE

ESURANCE

FARMERS

GEICO

THE HANOVER

LIBERTY MUTUAL

MAPFRE

MERCURY

METLIFE

NATIONWIDE

NJM

PROGRESSIVE

SAFECO

SAFETY

SHELTER

STATE AUTO

STATE FARM

TRAVELERS


Nontraditional and membership-based auto insurance reviews


Whereas most auto insurance companies cast their nets far and wide to get as many customers as possible, some restrict offerings to certain groups or tailor products to them. This helps them reduce risk, and in turn, they may offer lower prices to the customers they aim to serve.

AAA — typically restricted to AAA members.

AARP / THE HARTFORD — restricted in most states to AARP members.

CHUBB — white-glove insurance aimed at high-net-worth customers.

FARM BUREAU INSURANCE — typically requires membership in a Farm Bureau chapter.

GEORGIA FARM BUREAU INSURANCE

TEXAS FARM BUREAU INSURANCE

METROMILE — per-mile insurance for low-mileage drivers.

ROOT — rates based largely on driving behavior.

USAA — restricted to military members, veterans and their families.

WAWANESA — only insures drivers with clean records.



Auto insurance reviews for high-risk drivers


If you have a hard time getting coverage due to accidents, tickets, other violations or poor credit history, you may need to look for a different type of insurer. The companies below specialize in covering drivers who can’t get insurance elsewhere, and unlike some larger insurers will typically help out with an SR-22 filing. Also known as a certificate of financial responsibility, or an FR-44 in Florida or Virginia, this is a document your insurer files with your state to prove you have at least minimum coverage. (If you need an SR-22, you’d have been notified by a judge in traffic court or in a letter from your state’s department of motor vehicles.)

ACCEPTANCE

BRISTOL WEST

DAIRYLAND

DIRECT AUTO INSURANCE

FRED LOYA

GAINSCO

THE GENERAL INSURANCE

GOAUTO

GOOD2GO

INFINITY INSURANCE

KEMPER

NATIONAL GENERAL

SAFE AUTO

Auto insurance buying guide

Before you compare car insurance companies, you’ll need to collect basic information, such as the driving history of everyone on the policy and facts about your car, including safety features and annual mileage driven. You’ll also want to understand which types of coverage you need. For example, do you want only the bare minimum insurance that your state requires, or do you need more extensive coverage, such as gap insurance or rideshare coverage? Check that each company you’re considering has the options you want.

When comparing rates among insurers, make sure each is offering the same coverage limits and deductibles. You may not want to decide based on price alone. Look at how many consumer complaints each company has, as high numbers can be a red flag about the quality of service you might receive.

Depending on which company you choose, you may be able to buy insurance online, over the phone or through an agent. For more guidance, see how to get car insurance.

About the author