The Best Car Insurance Companies

Auto Insurance, Insurance

If you’ve ever shopped for auto insurance, chances are you’ve been inundated by cute animal mascots, charismatic actors or catchy jingles, all promoting a positive experience.

But when you cut away the noise and look inside the numbers, a clearer picture of which insurance companies are the cream of the crop emerges. NerdWallet rated insurers using customer and claims satisfaction scores from J.D. Power and consumer complaint data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. (Read our full methodology here.)

Our complete list:

The best car insurance companies

CompanyRatingFind rates
Note: Not all insurers are available in all states.
1. Amica


5.0-stars
5 stars

2. Erie

4.5-stars
4.5 stars

3. Auto-Owners Insurance

4.5-stars
4.5 stars

4. Country Financial

4.0-stars
4 stars

5. Nationwide

4.0-stars
4 stars

6. Geico
4.0-stars
4 stars

7. American Family

4.0-stars
4 stars

8. Allstate

4.0-stars
4 stars

9. The Hartford



4.0-stars
4 stars

10. Liberty Mutual

4.0-stars
4 stars

11. Safeco

4.0-stars
4 stars

12. Farmers

4.0-stars
4 stars

13. Mercury

3.5-stars
3.5 stars

14. Travelers

3.5-stars
3.5 stars

15. Progressive

3.5-stars
3.5 stars

16. Esurance

3.5-stars
3.5 stars

17. 21st Century

3.5-stars
3.5 stars

18. Automobile Club Group

3.0-stars
3 stars

19. State Farm

3.0-stars
3 stars

20. MAPFRE

3.0-stars
3 stars

21. The Hanover

3.0-stars
3 stars

Best for those with military ties: USAA


NerdWallet is a free tool to find you the best credit cards, cd rates, savings, checking accounts, scholarships, healthcare and airlines. Start here to maximize your rewards or minimize your interest rates. NerdWallet
Get a quote Available only to military members, veterans and their families.

USAA is open only to active military members, veterans and their families. If you’re eligible, it’s hard to go wrong with USAA. In addition to serving up consistently cheap car insurance quotes, the insurer earned the third-highest overall score in J.D. Power’s most recent nationwide auto claims satisfaction survey, and the highest for overall customer satisfaction in every region of the country.

» COMPARE: Car insurance quotes

How we calculated our ratings

Our final rankings include insurers available in at least five states and available to the general population.

NerdWallet’s star ratings are based on the following three factors, each weighted equally:

  • 2015 consumer complaints data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. The median complaint ratio for the industry is 1. Lower ratios are better. Insurers whose median complaint ratios were more than 1 received fewer points; those lower than 1 received more points.
  • 2015 regional customer service satisfaction data from J.D. Power. The higher the average J.D. Power rating across regions, the more points the insurer scored in our calculation.
  • 2015 auto claims satisfaction data from J.D. Power. The higher the J.D. Power rating, the more points the insurer scored in our calculation.

Only larger insurers with data available in all three of these categories were included. In case of ties, NAIC consumer complaints data were used to break the tie. Smaller insurers not listed here may also be good choices and are worth consideration.