By Joe Alfonso, CFP®, ChFC, EA, LTC
Learn more about Joe on NerdWallet’s Ask an Advisor
No one ever said you could live like royalty on Social Security. The program was always intended to provide a foundation for retirement but not to completely replace one’s working income. Having said that, it is wrong to ignore the importance of Social Security in developing a retirement strategy, given two key advantages Social Security benefits have over most other sources of retirement income: guaranteed lifetime benefits and annual cost of living adjustments, or COLAs.
Given the unique nature of Social Security income, it behooves us to do all that we can to maximize this benefit. But Social Security is a very complicated system comprised of myriad rules and regulations. It can be daunting to navigate these without a roadmap. While there is no replacement for working with an advisor familiar with the intricacies of the system, I’d like to offer the following 5 core principles to help anyone avoid major mistakes managing their Social Security benefit.
1. Don’t claim at age 62
One can claim a Social Security retirement as early as age 62. In some cases this is the right choice, such as when an unmarried person has a short life expectancy. In most cases, however, taking benefits before full retirement age (FRA) is a mistake given that doing so results in a permanent benefit reduction. For someone whose FRA is 66, taking a retirement benefit at age 62 results in a 25% benefit reduction. This shortfall might not seem like a lot initially, but its impact grows over time due to the effect of annual COLA adjustments. If, for example, one’s FRA retirement benefit at age 66 is $1,000/month, claiming at age 62 reduces this to $750, a $250 reduction. Assuming an annual COLA of 2.8%, this difference grows to $472 ($1,415 versus $1,887) by age 85, and continues to grow the longer one lives.
2. Delay taking benefits until age 70
The counterpoint to the benefit reduction that results from early sign-up is the credit earned for delaying the start of benefits past full retirement age. For each year you wait beyond that age, you can earn delayed retirement credits (DRC) of 8%. For the retiree whose FRA is 66, therefore, waiting to claim benefits until age 70 results in a 32% increase in benefits. If the FRA benefit is $1,000, the age 70 benefit will be $1,320, excluding COLA adjustments. The impact is even more dramatic if we compare the delayed age 70 benefit to the early age 62 benefit for a retiree with a FRA of 66. The age 70 benefit with DRCs is fully 76% greater than the age 62 early benefit! Clearly, delaying past FRA yields significant additional lifetime income to those who take advantage of this strategy.
3. Maximize strategies for couples
The Social Security rules allow heterosexual married couples various claiming options that can be utilized to great effect. These involve optimizing when spouses respectively claim spousal and retirement benefits in order to maximize lifetime cumulative income. These strategies are only possible after FRA.
The “File and Suspend” strategy allows a high-earning spouse who wishes to delay his retirement benefit to age 70 to do so while enabling his spouse to claim a spousal benefit. Essentially, the higher earner waits until his FRA to file for his retirement benefit. He then immediately suspends that benefit so that it can earn DRCs until age 70. At the same time, the lower-earning spouse, who also needs to be at FRA, files a “restricted application” for the spousal benefit triggered by her husband’s filing for his benefit. She then has the option to continue receiving a spousal benefit, or switching at age 70 to her own benefit if it is higher.
The “Take Some Now, Take More Later” strategy is another benefit maximization strategy available to spouses. In this scenario, the lower-earning spouse files for her retirement benefit at her FRA. This enables her spouse at his FRA to file a restricted application for a spousal benefit. The higher earner continues to receive the spousal benefit until age 70, at which time he switches to his own retirement benefit, which has been maximized as a result of earning DRCs.
Deciding which of the above strategies yields the best result requires analysis and depends on the respective ages and FRA retirement benefits of the spouses. Given the lifetime income maximization opportunities these strategies present, it is important for spouses to plan ahead before reaching FRA to decide on the strategy that is best for their particular situation.
4. Know your options as a divorced spouse
Many divorced spouses are unaware that they may be entitled to spousal or survivor benefits on the record of their former spouse. The key criteria are whether the marriage lasted at least 10 years and whether the claimant spouse has remarried or not. Divorced spouse benefits are not available if the claimant has remarried. Survivor benefits are not available to a divorced spouse if she remarries before age 60 (or 50 if disabled). Note that while survivor benefits are available as early as age 60 (or 50) and spousal benefits at age 62, they will be reduced if taken before FRA.
Divorced persons, especially those whose former spouses were the high earners in the marriage, should contact SSA if they believe they qualify for benefits under the above rules.
5. Go back to work if you need to
FRA retirement benefits are calculated using a formula that first averages the highest 35 years of income earned over one’s working career. Many people, especially women who dropped out of the workforce in whole or in part to raise a family, either do not have a full 35 years of earnings history or, even if they do, have years with relatively low earnings. That means that low or no-earnings years will be added to the 35 year average, ultimately resulting in a lower FRA benefit. Going back to work is a guaranteed way to increase your ultimate retirement benefit to the extent you can eliminate lower-earning years from the benefit calculation.
Social Security is a complex system and the above is not meant as an exhaustive review of its intricacies. My hope is that by highlighting the above strategies, you will be able to see how they may apply to your specific circumstances and be empowered to make better claiming decisions, whether on your own or while working with an advisor with expertise in this area.