How to Choose Your Second Credit Card

You’re not obligated to stick with any card through thick and thin. You’re probably better off if you don’t.
Claire Tsosie
By Claire Tsosie 
Edited by Paul Soucy

Many or all of the products featured here are from our partners who compensate us. This influences which products we write about and where and how the product appears on a page. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own. Here is a list of our partners and here's how we make money.

Loyalty to family and friends matters. Loyalty to your first credit card? Not so much.

A little over 30% of cardholders reported carrying only one credit card in a 2022 NerdWallet survey.

But you’re not obligated to stick with any credit card through thick and thin. In fact, you’re probably better off if you don’t. Getting a second card that fits your spending habits can earn you more rewards or save you on interest.

When to apply

There’s no perfect time to apply for a second credit card. As long as getting one will save you money and you're not about to apply for a mortgage, you’re probably in the clear.

But it might be an especially good time to apply if:

  • Your credit has improved. You'll now have access to better credit card options.

  • Your spending habits have changed. If your card offers bonus rewards only on restaurants, for example, and you no longer dine out often, it might be time for a change.

  • You want more rewards or benefits. Two credit cards can get you more perks than one.

  • You’re carrying high-interest debt. Moving your debt to a balance transfer card can save you money on interest.

To be sure, doubling up on your plastic won’t help in every case. If you already have trouble controlling your credit card spending or managing your account, opening another card will just add to your problems. But if you think a new card could benefit your bottom line, start looking.

What to look for

Getting a second card that complements your spending habits is key.

If you plan on carrying debt, find a card that minimizes the costs of doing so. Look for one with:

If you plan to pay in full every month, your interest rate won't matter. Instead, look for a card with:

  • High ongoing rewards, such as 1.5% or 2% back on every purchase. If you already have one of these cards, sign up for one that offers tiered rewards — that is, higher rewards rates in certain categories.

  • Rewards that fit your spending. If you’re always on the road, get a travel card that gives you points or miles. If you aren’t, go for one with cash back.

  • Side benefits. If you're a frequent traveler, a card that provides free checked bags or allows you to avoid foreign transaction fees could save you money.

Finally, keeping your first credit card open will generally improve your credit. But if you aren't using that card and it charges an annual fee, or if it’s a secured card and you want your deposit back, ask your issuer about converting it to a no-fee or an unsecured card. If those aren't options, close it.

Should you get a third credit card? … And a fourth?

Two credit cards might be better than one. And a third can boost your rewards rates further. But spreading your purchases over, say, 10 cards? It might not hurt you, but it probably won’t help you much, either — at least not in the long run.

The more cards you have, the greater chance there is that their core benefits will overlap. And applying for cards to get their sign-up bonuses and closing them afterward might help you rack up rewards, but using a patchwork of different cards on an ongoing basis probably won't. As your collection grows, multiple annual fees could eat away at your rewards, and your wallet could become more difficult to manage.

Keep your credit card collection a lean, mean, benefit-generating machine. Choosing a second card that's worthy of a space in your wallet is a great place to start.

Find the right credit card for you.

Whether you want to pay less interest or earn more rewards, the right card's out there. Just answer a few questions and we'll narrow the search for you.

Get Started
Get more smart money moves – straight to your inbox
Sign up and we’ll send you Nerdy articles about the money topics that matter most to you along with other ways to help you get more from your money.