Advertiser Disclosure

Consumers Credit Union Auto Loans: 2020 Review

Feb. 25, 2020
Auto Loans
Many or all of the products featured here are from our partners who compensate us. This may influence which products we write about and where and how the product appears on a page. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own.
3.0 NerdWallet rating

Good for: Borrowers who want flexible loan terms and like the services offered by a credit union

Consumers Credit Union offers an array of auto loans to a wide range of potential borrowers, though you’ll have to become a member to get a loan. The lender refinances existing auto loans and provides purchase loans for new and used cars from both dealers and private parties, as well as other types of vehicles.

Consumers Credit Union is a good fit for those who:

  • Have fair or good credit: The credit union will lend to those with scores as low as 640.
  • Want flexible loan terms: Loans can be as small as $250 and as brief as six months.
  • Are serious auto loan shoppers who don’t mind a hard credit pull to see rates.

Consumers Credit Union at a glance

APR*2.69% - 21.99% (with automatic payment discount)
Loan amounts$250 - $500,000
Minimum requirementsCredit score: 640
Income: $6,000/year gross
Membership: $5 fee, plus $5/month minimum savings account balance
Hard credit check with application?Yes
AvailabilityAll 50 states

*Annual percentage rate is used to evaluate the true cost of borrowing money and includes the interest rate.

Consumers Credit Union review details

Consumers Credit Union is an Illinois-based credit union, but don’t let that stop you from applying — it lends nationwide, including to those with fair credit.

If you’re on solid financial ground and can afford a new car loan, Consumers Credit Union makes the application process easy. You can apply online, over the phone or even over a video call with a representative. Most application decisions are made within 24 hours.

Be aware that Consumers Credit Union requires a hard credit pull to determine your creditworthiness. This slightly lowers your credit score, which means it’s best for serious car shoppers who are ready to get a loan. Once the loan is finalized, the funds can be mailed to you or the dealer as a cashier’s check or directly deposited into an account.

The credit union also offers refinancing for your existing car loan, with few restrictions on vehicle age and mileage.

Note that you can apply as a nonmember, but you’ll need to join the credit union to get a loan. Members can get rate discounts on their loans when they arrange automatic payments: 0.5% with automatic payments from a Consumers Credit Union account and 0.25% with automatic payments from another financial institution.

Car loan rates

The best interest rate offered by Consumers Credit Union is available only for applicants with excellent credit and loans of 36 months or less for newer vehicles. Lenders set their own requirements, but in general credit scores are categorized as follows:

  • 300-629: Bad credit.
  • 630-689: Fair credit, also called “average credit.”
  • 690-719: Good credit.
  • 720 and up: Excellent credit.

Interest rates will typically depend on your credit score, with lower scores meaning more expensive loans. Consumers Credit Union loans carry a maximum APR of 21.99%. However, the average rate for its customers is 5.09%, signaling a focus on borrowers with stronger credentials. The credit union will lend to those with scores as low as 640.

Knowing your credit score will give you an idea of the interest rate you might qualify for. Shop around if you have bad credit. You’ll likely be offered high interest rates, and comparing prices can help you save.

Applying to Consumers Credit Union

  • Loan offers good for up to 60 days; applicants are not obliged to accept.
  • No application fee; $29 late fee after 10-day grace period for missed payments.
  • Co-signers allowed.
  • Loan decisions in 24 hours.
  • Applications accepted online, over the phone, or in person in Illinois.


  • Loan terms: 6 to 84 months (NerdWallet doesn’t recommend loans over 60 months for new cars).
  • Maximum vehicle age: No restrictions; however, vehicles that are 2011 models or older are financed at higher, collateralized loan rates.
  • Maximum vehicle mileage: No maximum, though applications for cars with over 100,000 miles will be scrutinized more closely.
  • Minimum income: $500/month ($6,000/year gross), but the lender prefers $2,000/month for individuals and $3,000/month for joint accounts.
  • Membership requirements: $5 fee, plus savings account with $5/month minimum balance.
  • Available in 50 states.

How Consumers Credit Union compares

Setting it apart from other lenders we’ve reviewed, Consumers Credit Union is a full-service credit union offering an array of additional financial services. If you don’t qualify for a loan due to poor credit, for example, the lender can set you up with a partnered credit counseling agency to help you get on track to a better credit score. Since credit unions are owned by members, they tend to offer a more personalized approach to banking.

The table below shows how Consumers Credit Union stacks up to other lenders that offer purchase and refinance loans. Some companies provide loans directly, and others may shop for loans for you from a lending network of partners.

CompanyMin credit scoreMin monthly incomeAPRsHard pull?Get started
3.5 NerdWallet rating
500$1,8002.74% - 27% Yes
Consumers Credit Union
3.0 NerdWallet rating
640$500; $2,000 preferred2.69% - 21.99%Yes
5.0 NerdWallet rating
660None3.49% - 8.34%***Yes
Capital One
4.0 NerdWallet rating
500$1,500 - $1,800As low as 2.99%*No
*For excellent credit and new vehicle purchase **Max varies by state ***With autopay discount

CompanyMin credit score, monthly incomeGet started
3.5 NerdWallet rating

3.5 NerdWallet rating

Consumers Credit Union
3.0 NerdWallet rating

$500; $2,000 preferred
5.0 NerdWallet rating

Capital One
4.0 NerdWallet rating

$1,500 - $1,800
3.0 NerdWallet rating


More from Consumers Credit Union

As a full-fledged credit union, Consumers Credit Union offers all the products and services you’d expect from a bank. This includes checking accounts, online banking, credit cards, business loans and more. The lender also provides loans for motorcycles, recreational vehicles and boats and offers an auto-buying program and mechanical repair coverage. Consumers Credit Union’s robust online resources include a financial literacy program, user guides and an auto affordability calculator. If you want to talk with a representative “face to face,” the lender offers video calling from its app.

Shopping for an auto loan

Auto Loans Ratings Methodology

NerdWallet’s auto loans ratings reward lenders offering the most transparency and consumer-friendly features. Ratings are based on weighted averages of several categories, including flexibility of loan options, clarity of borrower requirements, accessibility, speed of funding and fees. Using our editorial discretion, we also consider consumer reviews and complaints. These ratings are a guide, but we encourage you to shop around to find the lowest interest rate you can qualify for. NerdWallet does not receive compensation for any reviews. Read our editorial guidelines.

About the author