Best of

6 Best Nonbank Mortgage Lenders of 2023

See NerdWallet's picks for the best nonbank mortgage lenders of 2023 across different categories.

By
NerdWallet
Feb 2, 2023

Some or all of the mortgage lenders featured on our site are advertising partners of NerdWallet, but this does not influence our evaluations, lender star ratings or the order in which lenders are listed on the page. Our opinions are our own. Here is a list of our partners.

Best Nonbank Mortgage Lenders

Lender
NerdWallet Rating
Min. credit score
Min. down payment
Learn more
Pennymac

Pennymac: NMLS#35953

Learn moreat Pennymac
at Pennymac
Best for FHA loans

620

3%

Guaranteed Rate

Guaranteed Rate: NMLS#2611

5.0
/5
Best for digital convenience

620

3%

Better

Better: NMLS#330511

5.0
/5
Best for refinancing

620

3%

Rocket Mortgage, LLC

Rocket Mortgage, LLC: NMLS#3030

Learn moreat Rocket Mortgage, LLC
at Rocket Mortgage, LLC
4.5
/5
Best for digital convenience

620

3%

Learn moreat Rocket Mortgage, LLC
at Rocket Mortgage, LLC
New American Funding

New American Funding: NMLS#6606

Learn moreat New American Funding
at New American Funding
4.5
/5
Best for nontraditional credit histories

580

5%

Learn moreat New American Funding
at New American Funding
Pennymac
Learn moreat Pennymac
at Pennymac
Pennymac

Pennymac: NMLS#35953

5.0
Min. credit score

620

Min. down payment

3%

Why We Like ItGood for: borrowers seeking a government-backed mortgage who want to rate-shop online.
Pros
  • Offers a wide variety of loan products, including government-backed and refinance options, as well as home equity loans.
  • Displays custom rate quotes based on home value, down payment or equity, ZIP code and credit score range.
  • “Lock & Shop” lets you secure a rate for up to 60 days, even if you don’t have a purchase contract yet.
Cons
  • Origination fees are on the higher end, according to the latest federal data.
  • Doesn't offer home equity lines of credit or renovation loans.
Read Full Review
Guaranteed Rate

Guaranteed Rate: NMLS#2611

Min. credit score

620

Min. down payment

3%

Why We Like ItGood for: borrowers seeking a solid variety of loan types, including jumbo and interest-only options, and a totally online experience.
Pros
  • Displays detailed sample rates for many of its loan products.
  • Offers a wide variety of loans, including jumbo and interest-only products.
  • Offers low rates compared with other lenders, according to the latest federal data.
Cons
  • Doesn't offer home equity loans.
Better

Better: NMLS#330511

Min. credit score

620

Min. down payment

3%

Why We Like ItGood for: tech-savvy borrowers who prefer an online experience.
Pros
  • Offers a program allowing qualifying buyers to make cash offers.
  • Makes it easy to see customized mortgage rates.
  • Average interest rates are on the low end compared to other lenders, according to the latest federal data.
Cons
  • Doesn’t offer USDA loans.
  • VA loans are not available in every state.
  • Doesn't offer home equity loans.
Rocket Mortgage, LLC
Learn moreat Rocket Mortgage, LLC
at Rocket Mortgage, LLC
Rocket Mortgage, LLC

Rocket Mortgage, LLC: NMLS#3030

4.5
Min. credit score

620

Min. down payment

3%

Why We Like ItGood for: borrowers who appreciate a fully digital home loan experience with mortgage rates lower than other lenders’.
Pros
  • Streamlined online process with document and asset retrieval capabilities, as well as the ability to edit your preapproval letter.
  • Mortgage interest rates are on the low side compared to other lenders, according to the latest federal data.
  • Offers the option to work with loan officers by phone if desired.
Cons
  • Getting a customized interest rate requires a credit check, which can affect your credit score.
  • Doesn't offer home equity lines of credit.
  • Origination fees are on the high side compared with other lenders, according to the latest federal data.
New American Funding
Learn moreat New American Funding
at New American Funding
New American Funding

New American Funding: NMLS#6606

Min. credit score

580

Min. down payment

5%

Why We Like ItGood for: First-time home buyers and other borrowers looking for a broad array of loan choices.
Pros
  • Offers a wide variety of purchase and refinance mortgages with an emphasis on helping underserved communities.
  • Its home equity line of credit can be used for an owner-occupied or second home.
  • Offers a program to enable buyers to make cash offers.
Cons
  • Mortgage origination fees tend to be on the high end, according to the latest federal data.
Carrington

Carrington: NMLS#2600

Min. credit score

620

Min. down payment

5%

Why We Like ItGood for: first-time home buyers or credit-challenged borrowers interested in government loan products.
Pros
  • Offers multiple low-down-payment loan programs.
  • May consider alternative credit data, such as bank statements.
  • You can view customized rates for purchasing a home and apply online.
Cons
  • Doesn't offer home equity lines of credit.
  • Lender fees are on the high side, according to the latest federal data.

More from NerdWallet
Choosing an ethical mortgage lender
Calculate your mortgage payment
How much home can you afford?

Last updated on February 2, 2023

Methodology

The star ratings on this page reflect each lender's overall star ratings. Read more about how we determine those ratings.

The lenders on this page are chosen using this methodology:

NerdWallet reviewed more than 50 mortgage lenders, including the majority of the largest U.S. mortgage lenders by annual loan volume (measured among lenders with at least a 1% market share), lenders with significant online search volume and those that specialize in serving various audiences across the country.

For inclusion on this roundup, nonbank lenders must score a 4.5 or above according to our overall methodology.

NerdWallet solicits information from reviewed lenders on a recurring basis throughout the year. All lender-provided information is verified through lender websites and interviews. We also utilized 2021 HMDA data for origination volume, origination fee, average interest rate and share-of-product data.

To recap our selections...

NerdWallet's Best Nonbank Mortgage Lenders of 2023

  • Pennymac: Best for FHA loans
  • Guaranteed Rate: Best for digital convenience
  • Better: Best for refinancing
  • Rocket Mortgage, LLC: Best for digital convenience
  • New American Funding: Best for nontraditional credit histories
  • Carrington: Best for first-time home buyers
NerdWallet Pixel