“Alternative” may bring to mind renewable energy or a mixtape from the 1990s, but it has a place in the investing world, too, referring to just about any asset that is not stocks, bonds or cash.
What are alternative assets?
Buying gold or other precious metals? That’s an alternative investment.
Putting money into your brother’s new business for a cut of future profits? Purchasing employee shares in your pre-IPO company? Pumping thousands of dollars into a mint stamp, coin or vinyl record collection? Buying bitcoin? All are examples of alternative assets.
Most investor portfolios are made up of three key ingredients: equity assets (like stocks), fixed-income assets (bonds), and cash or cash equivalents, like money market funds. Any other asset is lumped into the catchall “alternative asset” category.
Why invest in alternative assets?
Interest in alternative asset investing — or “alts,” as industry people say — has grown since the financial crisis, as investors seek greater diversification into assets that don’t track the performance of stocks and bonds.
Interest in alternative asset investing — or ‘alts,’ as industry people say — has grown since the financial crisis.
For example, the Great Recession hurt stockholders and bond buyers alike with dropping share prices and lower yields (interest paid) on new bonds. The price of gold, however, rose from about $800 an ounce in October 2008 to more than $1,900 an ounce in August 2011.
But it’s a seesaw. The stock market has since rallied to the second-longest bull market in history, while the price of gold dropped to $1,080 an ounce in December 2015, before rising in value again. Alternative investments can be a powerful way to diversify a portfolio, but carry much higher risks and turbulence in value.
What to be wary of
Most investors will never seriously trade in alternative investments, and that’s OK — alts are often risky and lightly regulated, if at all. That means it can be hard to get transparency on pricing, that is, to know whether this asset is really worth what you’re paying or getting paid. Alts also are more “illiquid,” meaning they are more difficult to turn back into cash. Selling $1,000 in shares of a publicly traded stock is relatively easy; pricing and selling a $1,000 rare coin or record album, less so.
So caution is required: Financial advisors recommend that alternative investments make up no more than a 10% slice of any portfolio, according to a 2016 survey co-sponsored by the Financial Planning Association.
Common types of alternative assets
Most of the players in this speculative realm are institutional investors or the very rich. You may have heard of hedge funds, an alternative investment that often uses riskier financial instruments like derivatives to balance — or hedge — against other market risks. But government rules require hedge fund investors to have earned at least $200,000 in each of the past two years, or to have $ 1 million in assets excluding their primary residence. Private equity — think of the angel investors who put millions into startups — is also out of reach for the average investor, unless you own employee stock options at a private company before its initial public offering.
Alternative assets for the common investor include:
- Real estate: Real estate investing is purchasing property to generate income, rather than to be used as a residence. That can be buying a property to earn rental cash or buying shares in real estate investment trusts, which invest in companies that finance or run commercial properties. Investors can purchase publicly traded REITs through an online broker. (Want to know more? See this guide on real estate investing.)
- Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies: Bitcoin jumped from just under $1,000 to a peak of nearly $20,000 in 2017, drawing a great deal of interest from investors. But many in the financial services industry believe there are many reasons to be wary of its rise.
- Commodities: Cows, corn, oil, gold or other essential raw materials that are grown or mined are commodities, and buying and selling them is risky because the price can widely fluctuate for a variety of reasons. A drought can raise the price of corn, or a decision by the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries to drill more can lower the price of oil. Investors have access to these markets through mutual funds or exchange-traded funds that focus on commodities.
- Peer-to-peer (P2P) lenders: Led by companies such as Lending Club and Prosper, P2P lenders allow private investors to invest cash in nonbank companies that give commercial and personal loans. Critics worry that this new form of lending has yet to be tested by an economic downturn.
Other kinds of alternative investments include currencies through forex trading, carbon credits, art, stamps or other collectibles that potentially rise in value over time.
How to invest in alts
Some online brokers have limited trading in alternative assets or funds linked to them. But for many alternative assets, you need to buy directly from money managers and wealth management firms. That will carry higher fees, which will vary depending on the asset.
Regulations are less commonplace than in more traditional forms of investment like stocks and bonds, and the amount of public information to assess the value of the asset murkier. Knowing the market and potential risks for any alternative asset class will likely require more homework (and guesswork) for the consumer. So the caution “buyer beware” is especially true if you venture into the alt investing world.