When a 1.5% Cash-Back Credit Card Beats a 2% Cash-Back Credit Card

When you factor in sign-up bonuses, which tend to be lower or nonexistent on cards that offer 2% back or more, it changes the equation.
Written by Gregory Karp
Senior Writer
Edited by Kenley Young
Assigning Editor
Fact Checked

Many, or all, of the products featured on this page are from our advertising partners who compensate us when you take certain actions on our website or click to take an action on their website. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own. Here is a list of our partners and here's how we make money.

Developments in the credit card market — including new 2% cash back cards, bigger bonus offers and innovative reward structures — have altered the calculus for many credit card shoppers. As a result, we consider this page to be out of date. See our best cash back credit cards page for great options.

In comparing flat-rate cash-back credit cards, the decision seems easy: Pick the card with the highest rate of cash back. A credit card with 2% cash back or more beats a card that offers just 1.5% cash back, right?

Not always.

You have to factor in sign-up bonuses, which tend to be lower or nonexistent on cards that offer 2% cash back or more. In a typical case, you might have to spend tens of thousands of dollars on a 2% card to make up for the cash bonus you can earn quickly on a 1.5% card.

Here’s how to figure out which flat-rate cash-back card is right for you.

Ready for a new credit card?
Nerdwallet+ members can earn \$100 in rewards for paying their first bill on time with an eligible credit card.

Simple math

In the example of a 2% card versus a 1.5% flat-rate cash-back card, the difference is 0.5% on all your card spending. Also typical, the 1.5% card has a \$200 bonus, and the 2% card has none.

The question: How much spending must you do while earning an extra 0.5% on the higher-rate card to make up for not getting a new-cardholder bonus?

Do the simple math by dividing the amount of the bonus by the difference in cash-back rate. So:

\$200/0.005 = \$40,000

In other words, the 2% cash-back card is the worse choice until you hit \$40,000 in spending. That’s the break-even point.

🤓Nerdy Tip

Annual fees are uncommon on flat-rate cash-back credit cards, but if there’s an annual fee, it should factor into the math. Think of the annual fee as reducing your total cash back.

Use the calculator below to find the break-even amount for two cards you’re considering:

The next big question is how long will it take to break even? In our example, spending \$40,000 on the card might take three or four years for some people. For others, it might take nine months. Answering that question will help you choose.

A real example

A perennial NerdWallet favorite among flat-rate cash-back cards is the Citi Double Cash® Card. It essentially offers 2% cash back, 1% when you make a purchase, then 1% when you pay it off.

NerdWallet also likes the Capital One Quicksilver Cash Rewards Credit Card. It offers 1.5% cash back on all purchases and comes with this bonus offer: Earn a one-time \$200 cash bonus after you spend \$500 on purchases within 3 months from account opening.

This illustrates the scenario in the math above: It would take spending \$40,000 on the Citi Double Cash® Card before you made up for the cash bonus offer on the Capital One Quicksilver Cash Rewards Credit Card.

How to choose

Go with a higher rewards rate and no bonus if ...

You’re a high spender

You’ll quickly make up for not getting a sign-up bonus, and you'll continue to earn more cash back for your spending year after year.

You’re patient and value simplicity

If you don’t want to think too much about which credit card you have and will keep it for many years — say, three years or more — the higher-rate card is likely to be a better choice. You have plenty of time to make up for not getting a sign-up bonus before you think about switching cards.

Go with a lower rewards rate with bonus if ...

You’re a low spender

Take the bonus and the lower cash-back rate because it could take years of spending on the card before you earn enough cash back to make up for forgoing the sign-up bonus. Just make sure you spend enough initially to earn the sign-up bonus.

You want cash soon

If you value near-term rewards or need a cash infusion quickly, choose a card with a sign-up bonus.

You’re disloyal to your credit cards

Disloyalty to credit cards isn't a bad thing. If you are willing to readily switch cards and have the credit scores to handle it, applying for new ones every few years can pay off. It allows you to take advantage of the newest offerings and earn new sign-up bonuses. Sometimes lucrative bonuses and perks are offered for a limited time. Being opportunistic can pay off.

The flat-rate card isn’t your main card

If your spending on the flat-rate card is low because you use it only as the "everything else" card in conjunction with a bonus-category rewards card, the 1.5% card might be the better choice because you get that cash bonus quickly, assuming you earn the bonus by spending enough on the card soon after you get it. Your low spending means your break-even point might be years away if you go with a 2% card without a bonus.

Consider other factors, like 0% APR

The main point of a flat-rate cash-back card is rewards cash. But other factors can matter, too. A flat-rate card might have perks, like cell phone insurance, or no foreign transaction fees for using it abroad.

But the biggest one might be a 0% APR period. Some flat-rate cards offer lengthy periods of no interest on purchases and/or balance transfers. That’s a totally different consideration than cash back, but it could mean a big difference in dollars if you can avoid interest for a time.

In our real example, here are the 0% APR periods:

• Citi Double Cash® Card: 0% intro APR on balance transfers for 18 months, and then the ongoing APR of 19.24%-29.24% Variable APR.

• Capital One Quicksilver Cash Rewards Credit Card: 0% intro APR on purchases and balance transfers for 15 months; 19.99% - 29.99% variable APR after that; balance transfer fee applies.

In sum, sign-up bonuses matter in credit card math. It’s how 1.5% cash back can beat 2% cash back.

Find the right credit card for you.

Whether you want to pay less interest or earn more rewards, the right card's out there. Just answer a few questions and we'll narrow the search for you.

Get Started
MORE LIKE THIS
Get more smart money moves – straight to your inbox